If you had to back one qubit technology with your own money, which would it be?

Started by RayOfLight73, Oct 04, 2026, 10:40 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Topic: If you had to back one qubit technology with your own money, which would it be?   Views(Read 102 times)

RayOfLight73

We cover a lot of different quantum hardware on this forum. Superconducting circuits from IBM and Google, trapped ions from Quantinuum and IonQ, neutral atoms from Pasqal, QuEra and Atom Computing, photonics from PsiQuantum and Quandela, silicon spin qubits from Diraq and Intel, and more exotic approaches like topological qubits. Each camp insists its approach will scale best. I thought it would be interesting to put that to a personal test

Imagine you had to back one approach with a meaningful chunk of your own savings, with no option to diversify. Which technology would you choose, and why? I am not asking about specific companies or shares, just the underlying technology. Think of it as betting on which physics will win

Each platform has a clear case. Superconducting systems are fast and well funded but need huge fridges and lots of wiring. Trapped ions have excellent fidelity but are slower, while neutral atoms scale to thousands of qubits but have their own speed challenges. Photonics and silicon promise easier manufacturing, though they have further to go

It is also possible that more than one approach wins, each suited to different jobs. Or that something we barely talk about today ends up dominating. History is full of technologies that looked like the obvious winner and then faded

Pick your horse and make your case. Bonus points if you explain what would make you change your mind

Scholar95

Trapped ions have the best quality, and I think quality wins in the end. Error correction is far easier with good qubits

Speed can be engineered later. Quantinuum's fidelity numbers keep impressing me
Posted from my main account

Undertaker00

Refusing to pick is tempting. History suggests different approaches will suit different problems. But if forced, neutral atoms. Neutral atoms if my arm were twisted
It's only banter... mostly

Rob98

Neutral atoms for me. The scaling progress has been remarkable, with thousands of atoms trapped already. If they solve the speed issue, they could pull ahead

Caltech's 6,100 atom array convinced me. Atoms are identical by nature, which helps enormously. No two superconducting qubits are quite the same
Measure twice, post once

Always_Brett36

Superconducting is the safe bet. IBM and Google have the money, talent and roadmaps

Safe bets do not always win, but they rarely disappear. Google's error correction results add weight to that view. Safe bets also attract the best engineers
Always open to a good discussion

BitSus71

Silicon spin qubits are my long shot pick. The chip industry has spent trillions perfecting silicon manufacturing. If qubits can ride on that, scaling becomes a manufacturing problem rather than a physics one. That is a huge advantage

Restless Barrel

Photonics, because it works at room temperature for much of the system and plays well with fibre networks. PsiQuantum's approach is a huge gamble, but if it pays off it could be enormous. Fibre compatibility could matter hugely for networking too
It's not a bug, it's a feature

Ava84

What would change my mind is a clear demonstration of hundreds of logical qubits on any platform. Whoever gets there first probably wins the funding race
This signature exists in a superposition of witty and cringe until you read it.

Context Sookie

Topological qubits would be the dream if they ever work convincingly. Microsoft's claims have been controversial though, so I would not risk my savings yet

Majorana claims have been retracted before. Caution is wise
My team is always one signing away

Related Topics (4)