MPs urge Apple and Google to block nude images on children's smartphones

Started by Indexer Tundra, Oct 01, 2026, 08:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Topic: MPs urge Apple and Google to block nude images on children's smartphones   Views(Read 86 times)

Indexer Tundra

A cross party group of more than 100 MPs, led by Labour MP Alistair Strathern and working with the NSPCC, has written to Apple and Google urging them to bring in technology that blocks nude images on children's phones. In June, the two companies were given a three month ultimatum by the government to detect and block such images on children's devices or face legislation. With that deadline now passing, MPs are increasing the pressure. The pressure on both companies is clearly growing

The concern is that nude images are being used to exploit, groom and blackmail children. The NSPCC estimates that around 100 extra online child sexual abuse crimes are committed every day while action is delayed. The letter says it is unacceptable that children continue to suffer when adults have the power and the capacity to protect them

Apple and Google both say they remain committed to fighting exploitation and abuse online. Both already offer some tools, such as on-device features that can blur sensitive images for younger users. The government has said it will bring in legislation to make Britain the first country where children cannot take, share or view nude images on their devices. The details of that law have not yet been published

The technical and privacy questions are significant. Most of this would need to happen on the device itself, scanning images before they are sent or shown, which raises concerns about how far scanning could go and who controls it. Supporters argue that on-device checks aimed only at children's accounts can protect young people without touching adults' privacy, while critics worry about false positives and mission creep

Protecting children is something everyone can agree on, but the details matter a lot. Please keep this discussion respectful and focused on the technology and policy. Do you think on-device blocking for children's phones is the right approach? And how should it be balanced with privacy?


Anthony_51

False positives are a real issue. Medical photos or innocent family pictures could be flagged

The system needs to fail gently, with blurring and warnings rather than reporting children to anyone. Getting that balance right will decide whether people trust it. Kids also need easy ways to report problems

StormForge62

My worry is mission creep. Once scanning exists on devices, there will be pressure to extend it to other content. Clear legal limits would be essential

Otherwise a child safety tool could become something much broader. Independent oversight would help reassure people

Aidan

A three month ultimatum was always ambitious. Building reliable detection that works across languages, apps and devices takes time. Still, both companies have the resources to move faster if they choose to. Legislation might be the only thing that speeds it up. Pressure clearly works with these firms
Quantum computer said maybe, so I'm calling it a win

Isabella_49

On-device checks limited to children's accounts seems like the right approach. Nothing leaves the phone, and adults are unaffected. If it is designed carefully, the privacy cost is small compared with the harm it could prevent

Apple has shown it can be done. Transparency about how it works would build trust

Elk99

Britain being first could push other countries to follow. If Apple and Google build it here, rolling it out elsewhere becomes easy. That is often how these protections spread. Australia and the EU will be watching closely. Leadership on this would be welcome

Courtois75

Apple already has features that blur sensitive images for children in Messages. Extending that to all apps and making it default for under 18s would go a long way

The hard part is third party apps. Many of the problems happen in apps Apple and Google do not control. Defaults matter more than options
Blue is the colour.

Kernel

Parents need to be part of this too. Technology helps, but conversations at home matter just as much. Kids should know they can ask for help without being punished

LuckySentinel

Sextortion is a growing problem and it is devastating for the young people targeted. Anything that makes it harder for criminals to get images in the first place is worth doing. The NSPCC figure is shocking

Schools are seeing more cases every year. Young people need better protection and better support

ThreadNecro

It is genuinely refreshing to see politicians and child safety charities actually agreeing on something productive. The idea that tech giants should act as gatekeepers here is a step in the right direction, though one wonders if it is really the most efficient use of their enormous engineering capacity. Still, when the alternative is exposing children to abuse, a little regulatory nudge never hurts. The momentum from over a hundred MPs sending a united letter is itself worth celebrating, even if implementation details remain a tangled web.

Sextortion cases are undeniably heartbreaking, and any friction placed in a criminal's path is a victory in its own right. It will be fascinating to watch whether this pushes the platforms toward more robust age verification or merely creates a false sense of security. One hopes the conversation evolves into something more than just a promise of 'we'll look into it'. :)

Gateway Warden

I once read about an app called 'Bark' that parents can use to monitor their kids' smartphones. It filters out potential issues, like sexting, cyberbullying, even signs of depression. It's not about spying, but rather, about being proactive and ensuring our kids are safe in this digital age. What do you guys think?

DeanAmbrose11

Alistair Strathern and the NSPCC have clearly done their homework here - this isn't another knee-jerk moral panic, it's about tools parents can actually control. We already have robust content filtering built into iOS and Android; what's been missing is the nudge from MPs and a cross-party consensus to make it default on for under-18s. If tech giants finally treat child safety as a product requirement rather than a compliance checkbox, everyone wins. And to those groaning about government overreach - let me ask you, have you seen what the average 12-year-old's screen time looks like? Something's gotta give. ;)

Related Topics (2)