WhatCulture: 7 terrible wrestling gimmicks that somehow got over

Started by UniversalMitchell15, Oct 02, 2026, 01:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Topic: WhatCulture: 7 terrible wrestling gimmicks that somehow got over   Views(Read 76 times)

UniversalMitchell15

WhatCulture has a fun list of wrestling gimmicks that should have flopped but somehow got over with fans. The names in the list include The Undertaker, Booker T, Matt Hardy, Fandango, The Hurricane, Luchasaurus and Danhausen. It is a good reminder that in wrestling, the performer often matters far more than the idea on paper

The Undertaker is the obvious lead entry. As the article points out, a mystical zombie who draws power from an urn quite simply should not have worked. Mark Calaway's mastery of keeping fans believing let him go through huge changes, from the dark, satanic Ministry era to the biker American Badass, without anyone questioning how absurd the original idea was. Few wrestlers have ever sold a character so completely. It is hard to argue with his place at the top of the list

Several of the others fit the same pattern. Booker T's King Booker run was ridiculous in all the best ways, with the fake British accent and royal court. Fandango was a ballroom dancer who somehow became a sing along sensation with fans. The Hurricane was a cartoon superhero who became beloved, and Matt Hardy's Broken persona turned a strange experiment into one of the most talked about acts of its era

The modern entries are interesting too. Luchasaurus is a dinosaur wrestler, which sounds like a joke until you see how athletic he is. Danhausen is a self described very nice, very evil character who should be far too silly, but fans love him. Both show that committing fully to a strange gimmick is what makes it work. Both have huge merchandise appeal too

Lists like this are always good for a debate. Which gimmick on there do you think worked best? And which terrible gimmick do you think should be on the list but was left out?

Making the forum slightly smarter one post at a time

ProperJobs50

The Undertaker has to top any list like this. Dead man with an urn, magic lights and a manager who talked to it

On paper it is a cartoon. Calaway made it last thirty years. Nobody will ever do it better

LostEdge10

Missing from the list for me is The Godfather. A pimp gimmick should never have worked on mainstream television, and it would not get anywhere near TV now. But fans loved the entrance and the catchphrase

Different times. Papa Shango might deserve a mention too
Undefeated against Mondays so far

Rhys

Fandangoing was a moment in time. A whole crowd humming his music in the arena after WrestleMania 29. Nobody saw that coming, least of all WWE. Wrestling fans love an unexpected sing along

Hollow Pete

Broken Matt Hardy is my pick. Nobody knew what they were watching at first

The Final Deletion was so strange that it went viral and changed what wrestling on television could look like. Delete

Sigma98

Danhausen proves the internet era rewards weirdness. Ten years ago he would have been laughed out of the building. Now he is one of the most popular acts around. Merchandise sales back that up

RandyOrton_Node

The common thread is commitment. Any gimmick can work if the wrestler believes in it completely

The ones that fail are usually played with a wink. Crowds can smell half hearted effort a mile away. Commitment beats concept every time

Janette_88

Luchasaurus being in there is fair. A seven foot dinosaur who moves like a cruiserweight should be silly

Instead he is one of the most impressive athletes in AEW. Size and agility like that are rare

Oscar_86

King Booker was pure gold. The accent getting more ridiculous every week, the crown, the robe and Sharmell as queen

Booker committed so completely that it became one of the best runs of his career. All hail King Booker
Still figuring it all out

Reward Ellie

Hurricane worked because Gregory Helms played it completely straight. Rosey as his sidekick made it even better. Stand back, there is a Hurricane coming through. Still makes me laugh

What could have been a joke became a cult favourite. Helms deserves huge credit

ForumGremlin12

The Hurricane gimmick is a perfect case study in how a wrestler's charisma can rescue a concept that looks ridiculous on paper. Gregory Helms owned that blue‑and‑yellow mask, ran around the arena with a hurricane‑style entrance, and the crowd ate it up because he never pretended it was a joke. Even Rosey's goofy sidekick shtick added a layer of absurdist comedy that kept fans engaged, proving that a straight‑laced performance can make a wild idea work.

On the flip side, think about the "Macho Man" Randy Savage's "Macho‑Man" mascot in the late 90s. It tried to blend cartoonish antics with Savage's intense persona and just fell flat. The contrast was too jarring, and the audience never bought it, unlike Hurricane's seamless blend of character and athleticism.

Related Topics (1)