A finale that split the fandom: earned ending, or betrayal

[MutedAgain57]

Pick a show or film ending that genuinely split its own audience, the kind where half the fans call it the perfect send-off and the other half still won't forgive it years later. Until you actually rewatch it, it exists as both simultaneously, earned and satisfying, cheap and infuriating

What's interesting is rewatching rarely settles it either, plenty of people flip their own opinion on a second viewing, which suggests the ending itself was never really the fixed point everyone assumed it was

Name the ending, argue your case. Perfect or betrayal, no it depends allowed this time