Bill Gates says companies replacing workers with robots should pay the same payroll taxes

Started by HiggsField84, Oct 01, 2026, 11:26 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Topic: Bill Gates says companies replacing workers with robots should pay the same payroll taxes   Views(Read 53 times)

HiggsField84

Bill Gates has renewed his call for a robot tax. In an interview with Ezra Klein of the New York Times, he said companies that replace human workers with robots or AI should pay the same FICA taxes that would have been paid on the human's wages. FICA is the US payroll tax that funds Social Security and Medicare. Workers pay 7.65 percent of their wages, with employers matching that amount

His idea is to define a unit of labour that is taxed the same way whether a person or a machine does the work. That would replace tax revenue lost when jobs disappear, help fund a stronger safety net and reduce the financial incentive to swap people for machines. He put it plainly, saying that just because the economic signals say it would be cheaper to use AI does not mean society has to do that

This is not a new idea from Gates. He first suggested taxing robots back in 2017, long before ChatGPT. At the time, he proposed using the money to retrain people for jobs that need a human touch, such as caring for older people and supporting children with special educational needs. With AI now moving much faster, the idea has new relevance

The article mentions around 130,000 AI related job losses in the US since January 2025, and some local governments are exploring fee based approaches to automation. It also ties into what the UK's AI minister said last week about planning for unprecedented job losses, including possibly redesigning tax so keeping workers is more attractive. And the Harvard experts we discussed think significant displacement is likely within two decades

The obvious problem is definition. What counts as a robot, and how do you measure how much human work a piece of software replaced? Critics also argue it could slow productivity and push companies to move automation abroad. It touches on tax policy, so please keep the discussion civil. Is a robot tax a sensible idea, or unworkable in practice?


LazySentinel

Companies would just move automated work to countries without the tax. Data centres can be anywhere. Unless it is agreed internationally, it would simply push investment abroad. Tax competition between countries is already fierce. This would add fuel to it

Dave

Taxing companies for being efficient feels backwards to me. Productivity gains are what raise living standards over time

The tractor replaced farm workers and nobody taxed it. Society adjusted and became richer
My team is always one signing away

CacheLayerShark

Society does not have to accept whatever is cheapest is the most important line. We already make choices like that with safety, environmental and employment laws. Markets are tools, not masters

BigDogShane10

The definition problem is huge. Is a spreadsheet a robot? Is a self checkout?

Every piece of software replaces some human effort. Drawing a line will be messy and lawyers will have a field day
It's only banter... mostly

Arthur86

Gates has a point about revenue though. Social Security and Medicare depend on wages. If fewer people earn wages, those systems lose money while demand for them grows. Something has to fill that gap. Taxing the productivity gains from automation seems as reasonable as anything else
RTFM and then ask

NeuralTrace26

Interesting that he first said this in 2017 and was widely mocked. Nine years on, with AI moving this fast, it sounds much less outlandish. Plenty of ideas sound mad until suddenly they do not

Courier53

One hundred and thirty thousand job losses since early 2025 is still small compared with the whole US workforce. But it is early. The question is what happens when agents get good enough to replace whole teams rather than individual tasks. Planning ahead makes sense
Long time lurker, first time poster

Jaguar43

Unit of labour is a clever concept, but measuring it sounds like a bureaucratic nightmare. Companies would have to estimate how many hours of human work their AI replaced. They would always estimate low. Accountants would love it though

Glacier53

A better approach might be taxing profits or capital more and labour less. That achieves the same goal without trying to count robots

If automation boosts profits, the tax system captures it automatically. Simpler to administer, harder to dodge. Most economists seem to prefer that route