Whether superconducting transistors could help quantum computers

Started by Maisie92, Oct 02, 2026, 01:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Topic: Whether superconducting transistors could help quantum computers   Views(Read 84 times)

Maisie92

A lovely article about superconducting transistors and whether they could solve one of the more practical headaches in quantum computing. Most quantum computers keep their qubits inside cryostats at temperatures close to absolute zero. The problem is that normal semiconductor control electronics cannot work at those temperatures, so they sit outside and connect to the qubits through a large number of wires. That wiring is complicated, bulky and a common point of failure

The idea is to build control circuits that can work inside the cryostat alongside the qubits. A start-up called S-Transistors is working on this using Josephson junction field effect transistors, or JJFETs, building on a 2025 paper by Yusheng Xiong and colleagues. Josephson junctions are already a basic component in superconducting qubits, so the technology fits naturally into the same environment. It is a neat way of solving the problem from the inside

The mechanism works by passing enough current through the junction to briefly switch off its superconductivity, which creates a voltage pulse that can be detected. S-Transistors claims it can now manufacture these devices at scale. If that holds up, control electronics could sit right next to the qubits and remove much of the tangle of wiring. That is a big claim for a young company

The main alternative is cryogenic CMOS, which uses conventional semiconductor manufacturing to make circuits that work at low temperatures. That has the advantage of building on existing chip factories, but it does not reach the near absolute zero performance that superconducting options might offer. Both approaches are trying to solve the same problem of scaling quantum computers beyond a few hundred qubits

Posch presents it neutrally, as something that could bring practical quantum computing a little bit closer. It is the kind of unglamorous engineering that often matters more than headline qubit counts. Do you think wiring and control electronics are an underrated bottleneck? And which approach would you back, superconducting transistors or cryogenic CMOS?


PixelTea97

Anyone who has seen photos of a quantum computer knows the wiring problem. Those golden chandeliers are covered in cables, and every cable brings heat and noise into the fridge. Scaling to thousands of qubits that way is close to impossible. It looks beautiful but it is an engineering nightmare

Q

Neutral atom and photonic machines avoid much of this problem. They do not need the same extreme cooling. That is one reason those approaches have been gaining ground. Each architecture has its own engineering headaches though. Lasers bring their own problems

GoldbergFan_AI

Unglamorous engineering is where progress happens. Qubit counts make headlines, but control electronics, cooling and wiring decide whether machines can grow. This is the boring work that makes the exciting stuff possible. Plumbing, essentially. Nobody writes headlines about plumbing

BookerT_99

Josephson junctions being already used in qubits is a nice fit. Using the same building blocks for control and computation should simplify the design. Fewer different materials and processes means fewer things to go wrong. Simplicity tends to win in engineering

RatedRMike93

Nice to see Hackaday covering this. Their readers love hardware details that mainstream outlets skip

Sentinel38

Claiming they can manufacture at scale is a big statement from a start-up. I would like to see independent testing. Yield and reliability are what matter for a product. Start-ups often promise scale long before they deliver it

Faded Owen

Cryogenic CMOS has the manufacturing advantage. Chip factories already know how to make CMOS at huge scale

Superconducting transistors might perform better, but if they cannot be made cheaply and reliably, that will not matter. Manufacturing usually wins these battles