Poll: When do you think Q-Day will arrive

Started by Rory93, Today at 05:02 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Topic: Poll: When do you think Q-Day will arrive   Views(Read 80 times)
Active members in this topic:
Rory93(1) Karen88(1)

Rory93

TL;DR

  • Q-Day is the day a quantum computer can break the public key encryption that protects most of the internet today
  • Nobody knows the date, and expert estimates vary widely, which makes it a perfect subject for a friendly poll
  • The Global Risk Institute's Quantum Threat Timeline Report 2025 surveyed 26 experts, and averaged estimates for a code breaking machine within ten years ranged from roughly 28 to 49 percent depending on how answers were read
  • The UK NCSC has asked organisations to finish migrating to post quantum cryptography by 2035, with milestones in 2028 and 2031
  • Whatever you vote, the good news is that replacement algorithms already exist and the migration is well under way

Why we are asking

Q-Day is one of the most talked about ideas on this forum, yet it remains impossible to pin down. Some members think it is a few years away, others think it is decades off, and a few doubt it will ever arrive. That spread of opinion is not a sign of confusion. It reflects real uncertainty among scientists and engineers too

A poll is a fun way to see where our community sits. It also helps newer members understand that there is no single official answer. Before you vote, this post gives a short summary of what experts have said and why their estimates differ. Please read it, cast your vote and then tell us your reasoning in the replies

For anyone new to the topic, the threat concerns public key cryptography such as RSA and elliptic curve methods. These protect website connections, digital signatures, software updates and much more. A large, reliable quantum computer running Shor's algorithm, published by Peter Shor in 1994, could in principle break them. Today's machines are nowhere near large or reliable enough

What the experts say

Each year the Global Risk Institute publishes a Quantum Threat Timeline Report, created by Michele Mosca and Marco Piani. The 2025 edition surveyed 26 experts from academia and industry. Depending on how their answers are interpreted, the averaged chance of a cryptographically relevant quantum computer within ten years was put at roughly 28 to 49 percent. Over fifteen years, a clear majority of respondents rated the chance at fifty percent or higher

Resource estimates have also fallen over time. In May 2025, Google researcher Craig Gidney published an estimate that RSA-2048 could be factored in under a week by a machine with fewer than one million noisy qubits. That is far beyond any machine that exists today, but it is roughly twenty times fewer qubits than his 2019 estimate with Martin Ekera. Progress in algorithms can matter as much as progress in hardware

Governments have responded with clear timelines. In March 2025 the UK National Cyber Security Centre asked organisations to complete discovery and planning by 2028, carry out priority migration by 2031 and finish migration by 2035. In the United States, NIST's draft transition guidance proposes deprecating today's vulnerable algorithms from 2030 and disallowing them from 2035. These dates are about being ready in time, not predictions of when Q-Day will happen

Why estimates differ so much

Building a useful quantum computer needs many advances at once. Qubits must become more reliable, error correction must work at large scale and machines must run for long periods without failure. Each of these is a serious engineering challenge, and breakthroughs are hard to forecast. Experts who weigh these challenges differently will naturally reach different dates

Optimists point to rapid recent progress in error correction and to large investments by companies and governments. Sceptics point to the enormous gap between today's machines and the scale needed, and to the history of technologies arriving later than expected. Both views are reasonable. A poll like this simply captures how our community weighs the evidence

There is also a useful rule of thumb called Mosca's inequality. It says that if the time your data must stay secret plus the time it takes to migrate is longer than the time until Q-Day, you already have a problem. This is why organisations are acting now even though nobody knows the date. Preparation does not depend on winning the prediction game

Before you vote

There are no wrong answers in this poll. You might base your vote on news you have read, your professional experience or simple gut feeling. All are welcome, and so is changing your mind later. We may run the poll again next year to see whether opinions shift

However you vote, please remember that the outcome for ordinary users is reassuring. New standards such as ML-KEM and ML-DSA were published by NIST in August 2024, and many browsers and messaging apps already use post quantum protection. Keeping devices updated is still the most useful thing most people can do. The migration is happening quietly in the background

Questions to discuss

  • What most influenced your estimate
  • Do you think Q-Day will arrive before or after the 2035 migration deadline
  • Would a public announcement be likely, or could the first machine be kept secret
  • Has your estimate changed over the past few years

Closing thoughts

Predicting Q-Day is a bit like predicting the weather a decade from now, which is why a range of views is healthy. The important thing is that the world is preparing whatever the answer turns out to be. Vote, share your thinking and enjoy the debate. We will revisit the results in a future thread



Further reading

  • Global Risk Institute, Quantum Threat Timeline Report 2025, Michele Mosca and Marco Piani
  • Craig Gidney, How to factor 2048 bit RSA integers with less than a million noisy qubits, arXiv, May 2025
  • UK NCSC, Timelines for migration to post quantum cryptography, March 2025
  • NIST IR 8547 (initial public draft), Transition to Post-Quantum Cryptography Standards, November 2024
  • NIST FIPS 203 and FIPS 204, August 2024
404: Signature not found in this dimension

Karen88

Twenty years ago people said quantum computers were always twenty years away. That joke has aged less well than I expected. The error correction results of the last couple of years changed my view a lot. Machines are still small, but the direction is clear now. I used to be a firm sceptic

Mosca's inequality is the part everyone should remember. Waiting for certainty is not a plan

Even so, I would not lose sleep over it. The standards exist and the rollout is happening. Browsers protect most of my traffic already. Banks are moving more slowly, but they are moving. Patience and updates are the answer for most of us