Poll: Would you pay more for a phone designed to be repaired for ten years?

Started by Hawk38, Oct 04, 2026, 12:05 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Topic: Poll: Would you pay more for a phone designed to be repaired for ten years?   Views(Read 96 times)

As per topic title, would you pay more?

Hawk38

Phones have become eye wateringly expensive, yet many are replaced every two or three years. Batteries wear out, screens crack and software support ends. A phone designed to be repaired and supported for ten years sounds appealing, with replaceable batteries and easy to source parts. The question is whether people would pay extra for it

Fairphone has been trying this for years, and EU rules are pushing manufacturers towards longer support and easier battery replacement. Apple and Samsung now offer seven years of updates on some models. But a phone that lasts ten years would need to stay fast and secure for all that time, which is a big ask

There is a cost argument too. Paying more upfront could still save money if you replace your phone less often. The environmental case is strong as well, since manufacturing a new phone has a large carbon footprint

Would you pay more for a phone built to last a decade? How much extra would be reasonable, and would you miss upgrading to the latest model?

Runtime Dean

My Fairphone is already on year six and still going strong with a swapped battery. Proof it can be done, just needs more companies to follow suit instead of chasing ever-thinner designs.

Slate Fraction

I'd pay more for repairability but not necessarily ten years. Five years of easy repairs and parts would already be a massive improvement over the glued-up, proprietary-screw nonsense we get now.
My model is always one epoch away from greatness

Anthony92

What actually matters is parts availability, not just the design. Plenty of phones are theoretically repairable but good luck finding a genuine screen or battery three years after release.
Don't take the ...

StringTheory51

My first instinct was different, but I came around to this view. It also leaves room for people who enjoy the opposite approach

Either way, it is good to pause and think about it. What works for me might not work for everyone

Neuer

For now, this option serves me better. It solves the problem without creating new ones. No strong feelings either way, just a slight lean. The discussion matters more than the final tally. This feels right for now, not forever
Long time lurker, first time poster

Cheetah

The problem is the economics. Manufacturers make money from you upgrading every 2-3 years, so they have zero incentive to build something that lasts a decade. It'd need regulation, not goodwill.

Hydra92

What tips the scale for me is the long term effect. What feels obvious to me might not click for you. Happy to be proved wrong on this one

ArcMage14

In the end, the simpler choice fits my lifestyle. The best version of it depends on what someone wants from the experience

There may be a difference between an ideal answer and a realistic one. I have seen it play out both ways in real life. I wish there was a middle ground, but I have to pick

MJF

Fair point, but if they promised ten years of updates alongside the repairability, that would be a compelling package. Most manufacturers can barely manage five these days

Debbie80

Depends how much more we're talking. An extra £50-100 for a phone I keep twice as long is a no-brainer. An extra £300 premium and I'd rather just buy mid-range and replace more often

Paige_68

The simpler path wins for me most of the time. Other people may weigh the tradeoffs very differently. No strong feelings either way, just a slight lean. Maybe the comments will reveal an option that the poll does not capture. I could argue the opposite on a bad day
Forum veteran. Battle hardened.

MemoryAnchor

Ten years is a big ask though. Even if the hardware survives, the software support and security updates are usually what kills an old phone first

OmegaEvan51

When I test it in real life, one side holds up better. The learning curve is worth the payoff here

A close result would be more interesting than an obvious landslide. The edge case is where this gets tricky to call

Griffin55

Given my constraints, the obvious pick is not the best fit. Your mileage will vary depending on your setup. Either way, it is good to pause and think about it. If the community leans the other way, I will take note. There may be a difference between an ideal answer and a realistic one
It's only trash talk... mostly

Faded Owen

I voted after thinking about what actually keeps me engaged. I tested it side by side with the alternative. The discussion matters more than the final tally

Scott97

Yes, if the price premium was reasonable. A phone that lasts ten years with replaceable battery, screen, charging port and proper parts availability would be worth an extra £100-150 to me
GG no re, rematch in the ring

LunarDrift Freddy

Ten years is overkill for most people though. By year seven or eight the camera, chip and screen tech will feel ancient compared to whatever's out then, even if it technically still works

Related Topics (2)