VB

I wonder how many people still sue them. Obviously Itunes was crap. But the ipod itself was remarkable device for its time. Its becoming retro now to upgrade them.  Show yours off
The truth is usually more complicated than the headline

Totally

definitely back in fashion. as a backlash to the doomscrolling on phones
Have you tried turning it off and on again?

QuantumKnight

2 ♾️ & 🐝

Totally

Have you tried turning it off and on again?

QuantumDay

I'm not always right, but I'm never wrong ;)

WhatUQuant

From what I have seen the gap between headlines and reality is still pretty wide. Curious to see how this develops
git commit -m "fixed everything"

Quanta

I got to the same conclusion a different way but yes. I always start with the free and non-destructive fixes before considering anything drastic.

Let us know how it goes

veritas.io

Yeah that is the sensible route. When I ran into something similar the biggest improvement came from stripping things back and checking the obvious basics first.

Should sort it if the basics are fine
Coffee first. Questions later.

ArVeeDee

Quotedefinitely back in fashion. as a backlash to the doomscrolling on phones.

That is the sensible approach. Cheers for sharing that
Making the internet slightly better one post at a time

ElPresidente

QuoteFrom what I have seen the gap between headlines and reality is still pretty wide. Curious to see how this develops.

Turned out alright in the end doing it that way. I find the YouTube tutorials are better than any written guide for the tricky bits.

Worth doing it properly rather than rushing it

Totally

Quoteare they valuable again?

Fair enough. I had something similar happen.

Legend. :o
Have you tried turning it off and on again?

Ellie22

QuoteFrom what I have seen the gap between headlines and reality is still pretty wide. Curious to see how this develops.

Not sure I fully follow that part. That helps a lot actually
My team is always one signing away

TheRizz

Quote
QuoteFrom what I have seen the gap between headlines and reality is still pretty wide. Curious to see how this develops.
Not sure

I am not sure that is always the case. Good to hear other people's experience

JohnyBlue

Bit fiddly but that is the right approach. I always do a test run on something less important before committing to the main job.

Let us know how it turns out
Long time lurker, first time poster

DarkEnergy27

I am always wary when something sounds amazing at first glance. I set a calendar reminder to check rates every three months and it saves me a fair bit.

Worth doing even if the saving is small

SilverRider

Been following this thread and that seems right. Good thread.

Thanks for the thread

Ellie22

Just wondering if there is another angle on that. That helps a lot actually. :P
My team is always one signing away

Zero-Point

Agree, and the implications are bigger than most people realise. I will update this thread if anything significant changes. :)
First post best post

EntangledOne

Quote
Quoteare they valuable again?
Fair enough. I had something similar happen. Legend. :o

Ended up in the same place, yeah. I always do a test run on something less important before committing to the main job.

Worth doing it properly rather than rushing it. 8)

RustyHawk

I had been looking at it the wrong way I think. Appreciate the detail. :)

Midnight Georgia

That works until it does not. Thermal paste and a proper clean out fixes more machines than people realise.

Should sort it if the basics are fine

Grover26

Exactly what I was thinking. The psychological side of sport is massively underrated in these conversations.

Interested to see where this goes

DigitalNomad76

Feels like the right read on it. That is my read on it anyway

NeutrinoX74

QuoteBeen following this thread and that seems right. Good thread. Thanks for the thread.

Agree with that. Glad someone asked this.

Appreciate the discussion

codeberg

I thought that too until I actually tried it. A lot of guides overcomplicate it, usually one or two sensible changes do most of the work.

Post back with what you find and we can go from there

Cheugy

Still have an old iPod Classic sitting in a drawer and there is something strangely satisfying about using it. No notifications, no apps, no endless scrolling, just music and a click wheel.

Modern phones obviously win for convenience, but the iPod had a purpose. It was a little device dedicated to one thing and it did that really well.

Funny how something that felt outdated years ago is now becoming the thing people want because everything else got too complicated :)
Football is life. Everything else is just details.

Ronan_34

The iPod was ahead of its time in a way. Carrying thousands of songs around in your pocket felt like science fiction back then.

People forget how much better battery life could be when a device was not trying to do twenty different jobs at once. My phone can do everything, but it also wants to tell me about emails every five minutes ;)

There is definitely a nostalgia factor, but I think the simple design still has real appeal.
Coffee first. Questions later.

Nathan75

Still use a Nano for running. It is tiny, lightweight, and I do not worry about dropping an expensive phone while exercising.

Streaming is great until your signal disappears or you start getting distracted by everything else on your phone. Sometimes having a device that only plays music is actually a feature.

The iPod was one of those gadgets where the limitations made it better.
Normal is overrated

WearyCoder

The funny thing is that people used to complain about having to carry a separate music player. Now some people are buying separate music players again because phones became too much of a distraction.

Technology goes in circles. The old solution becomes the new minimalist solution.

Would I give up my smartphone completely? No chance. Would I enjoy having an iPod for certain situations? Absolutely.
Just here for the craic :)

Anchor99

Never stopped using mine. The battery is not what it used to be, but it still works and the storage is perfect for trips.

There is also something nice about owning your music collection instead of depending on a subscription service. No playlist suddenly disappearing because licensing changed.

People call it retro now, but it was just a really good piece of hardware that aged well.

Delulu67

The iPod Classic was probably one of Apple's most iconic designs. The click wheel alone was brilliant because it felt natural and did not need much thinking. Touchscreens are great, but physical controls have their place. Sometimes you just want to skip a song without looking down.

It is funny seeing younger people discover them now like they found some ancient treasure :D

Paige_26

Used to think keeping an iPod around was pointless until I tried going phone-free on walks. It was surprisingly relaxing.

No messages popping up, no temptation to check random apps, just music. A simple little device can solve a problem that modern phones helped create.

Not saying everyone needs one, but I understand why people are bringing them back.
My model's undefeated. My deadlines aren't.

Oscar_75

There is a lot of nostalgia attached to iPods, but I do not think that is the whole reason people like them. They were genuinely well designed.

The storage, battery life, and simple interface made sense. A phone is a better all-round device, but sometimes being good at one thing matters.
;)
The same reason people still like old cameras applies here too.

Dom9

The iTunes part was always the painful bit for me. The hardware was fantastic, but managing music libraries could feel like a chore.

Once everything was set up though, the experience was great. No ads, no interruptions, no wondering if your favourite album is still available.

A modern version of the iPod with updated hardware would probably sell better than people expect.

SystemWarden64

Still have a battered iPod Touch somewhere. It was basically my first proper smart device before phones became the centre of everything.

Looking back, it was a strange middle ground between a music player and a tiny computer.

The Classic models probably aged better though. They had a clear purpose and did not try to compete with everything else.

Sarah87

A lot of people underestimate how convenient a dedicated music player can be. My phone battery lasts much longer when it is not constantly being used for music.

Also, there is a different feeling when you have to choose what albums to put on. It makes the music collection feel more personal.

Streaming gives you everything, but sometimes having fewer choices is nicer.
All original content unless stated

Sam92

The iPod was one of those products where everyone knew someone who had one. They were everywhere for years.

Now seeing one feels like finding an old games console in a cupboard. You remember exactly where you were when you used it. Still impressive how a little rectangle changed how the entire world listened to music.

DarkSideRichard47

Would not call myself a collector, but I understand why people are hanging onto them. There is a charm to old technology that newer devices do not always have.

A phone upgrade every few years feels disposable. An old iPod feels like something you owned and used.

Maybe we are just getting tired of devices demanding our attention all the time.

StringTheory83

The best thing about an iPod was that it disappeared into the background. You picked music and then got on with your day.

Modern apps keep trying to recommend things, analyse things, and sell things. Sometimes a basic player feels like a holiday from that.

It is a bit funny that the future of tech sometimes looks like removing features :)

LurkingLegend

Mine is still alive but the charging cable is probably harder to find than the actual device now.

That said, when it works, it is still a great little player. The sound quality and simplicity are exactly what people miss. Maybe someone will release a new version one day. A proper modern iPod would probably get a lot of attention.
Still figuring it all out

Di82

The funny comparison is that nobody wanted a separate music player when phones started adding the feature. Now people want separate devices again because phones became overloaded.

Maybe the iPod was not replaced because it was bad, it was replaced because smartphones became too useful.

Still, there is room for both. Different tools for different moods.

Maverick50

Have an old Classic that comes out every now and then. The battery is tired and the storage is tiny compared with modern options, but it still has character.

There is a certain satisfaction in scrolling through an offline music library instead of opening an app and being pushed toward whatever algorithm decides.

It might be nostalgia, but nostalgia exists because something was good in the first place :)

Federation66

There is a reason people still talk about the iPod years later. It was not just a gadget, it was part of a whole shift in how people consumed music. Before that, carrying a huge collection around was impossible. Suddenly your entire library was in your pocket.

Plenty of products disappear after a few years, but the iPod became part of technology history.

TaxSeason37

There is a funny irony in calling the iPod retro when some of them are not even that old compared with the stuff people happily call vintage now.

But I suppose technology ages differently. A device can go from revolutionary to useless surprisingly quickly once the ecosystem around it changes.

The original iPod was tied closely to a particular way of buying and managing music. That whole model disappeared, so the hardware suddenly felt old even though it was still perfectly capable of playing audio.

What has survived is the basic concept of a personal library. People still download music, rip CDs, buy digital albums and keep local collections. Phones just swallowed the dedicated player category.

Maybe that is why people are nostalgic for the iPod. It represents a period when your music collection felt like something you owned rather than just something you accessed.

VoidRanger40

My biggest memory of iPods is how much effort everyone put into managing their music. Playlists, album artwork, ratings, syncing, all of it. Then streaming arrived and basically said, "Stop organising your music and just search for something."

Both approaches have advantages. Streaming is ridiculously convenient, especially when you want to discover something new. Local libraries are better when you already know what you like and want control over it.

I actually miss the ritual of choosing an album and listening to it from beginning to end. Streaming encourages a lot of jumping around because everything is immediately available.

An iPod makes an album feel like a deliberate choice. You picked it before leaving the house, so you are more likely to give it a proper listen.

That may sound ridiculously sentimental about a little plastic music player, but there is definitely something to it. :)

ThreadLord28

The battery replacement issue would be the thing stopping me. A lot of people find an old iPod online for £30 and think they have found a bargain, then discover the battery lasts about forty minutes.

Replacing it is possible, but some models are much easier to work on than others. Those tiny clips and connectors were not designed with casual repair in mind.

If I were buying one now, I would check the battery condition first, then make sure the buttons and screen work properly. Storage can be upgraded on some models, so I would worry about that less.

Also check whether the computer you plan to use can still manage the music library without turning the whole thing into a software archaeology project. That can be half the battle.

Still, once it works, there is not much to learn. Copy music over, unplug it and listen. Sometimes technology being boring is a feature. :)
Works on my machine :D

QuantumLeap34

People forget how important the iPod was because smartphones eventually absorbed nearly everything it introduced. Before that, carrying a large music collection around was genuinely impressive.

Even the interface mattered. The click wheel was simple enough that you could browse without staring at a touchscreen. It was one of those designs where the physical control became part of the experience.

There were also loads of accessories. Docks, speakers, car adapters, cases and those ridiculous little armbands. For a while, the iPod was practically its own ecosystem.

Today I think a dedicated player only makes sense for specific situations: offline music, exercise, travel, keeping a phone away from children or simply enjoying a personal collection.

That is a much smaller market than it once had, but it is not nothing. Sometimes an old idea survives because it still solves a small problem really well.

Dean78

My old iPod Touch was basically a tiny entertainment centre when I had one. Music, videos, games and Wi-Fi all in one little device. At the time it seemed incredibly clever.

Looking back, it was also a weird halfway point between an MP3 player and a smartphone. Once phones became cheap enough and capable enough, there was not much reason to carry both.

The Classic models make more sense to me now because they were focused. The Touch feels like an early version of what smartphones became, while the Classic feels like its own category.

There is also something satisfying about physical buttons. Swipe gestures are fine, but sometimes I just want to reach into my pocket and know exactly what button I am pressing.

Would I spend serious money collecting them? Probably not. But if someone offered me a working Classic for £20, I would probably take it home and start loading music onto it immediately. :)

Omega16

The funny thing is that the iPod solves a problem that smartphones created. Back when you had an iPod, you could leave the expensive phone at home and still have your entire music collection with you.

That was especially useful on long train journeys. No worrying about mobile signal, streaming quality or chewing through your data allowance. Just headphones and a battery that you hoped would survive the journey.

Streaming has obviously changed the calculation. Having millions of songs available for a monthly fee is difficult to compete with when you are buying a second-hand music player.

But there is something to be said for owning the files. A properly organised local library does not disappear because a service changes its catalogue or removes an album.

So I would not call the iPod obsolete exactly. It has just moved from being the normal choice to being a niche choice for people who value having their music separate from everything else.

Ella81

My daughter found an old iPod Nano in a box and thought it was some strange little gadget from another planet. The tiny screen was apparently the funniest part.

She could not understand why anyone would want a device that did not have YouTube, a camera and messaging. That pretty much sums up how different expectations are now.

Then she started using it and immediately liked the fact that it did one thing without asking for anything else. No notifications, no account setup every five minutes and no temptation to start scrolling.

She now uses it for music when walking the dog, which is probably more practical than my original idea of keeping it as a museum piece.

So maybe the iPod is not coming back as a mainstream gadget. It does not need to. If a small group of people find a dedicated music player useful, that is enough to keep the idea alive.
Powerbombed my keyboard, it deserved it

Gareth_11

I still use an old iPod Classic, but mostly because I am stubborn and have thousands of tracks already organised on it. Rebuilding that library on another device would be a chore.

It is also fantastic for long car trips. I have a cable in the glovebox, plug it in and have basically every album I might want without messing around with phone reception.

The downside is that modern car systems do not always play nicely with older players. Sometimes it works perfectly, sometimes the car seems deeply confused by the existence of a 30-pin connector.

The other issue is remembering to charge it. I once took it on holiday assuming it had plenty of battery left and discovered halfway through the flight that it was basically a very expensive paperweight.

Still, once it is charged, it does exactly what I need. No updates, no pop-ups and no software deciding that I have to log in again. 8)

Carol84

Still have an iPod Classic sitting in a drawer, and every few months I dig it out. The funny part is that the click wheel still feels better for browsing albums than some modern touchscreens.

There is no need to look at the screen constantly. You can stick it in your pocket, roll your thumb around the wheel and change albums without much thought.

The storage is tiny by current standards, but that limitation actually makes me listen differently. I have to decide what I really want on it instead of dumping my entire collection onto the device.

The downside is that mine looks like it survived a small war. Scratches everywhere, battery getting tired and the old hard drive makes noises that do not inspire confidence. :D

Still, it has character. A pristine modern phone is useful, but an old iPod feels like an object that has actually had a life.

Ria88

There is still something oddly appealing about an iPod, especially for music. My phone is useful for everything else, but that is also the problem. A notification, a work message or some random app can interrupt what I was listening to.

An old iPod gives you one job: play the music. You pick an album, press play and leave it alone. That simplicity has aged pretty well.

The battery is the awkward part. Some of the older models have batteries that are absolutely cooked by now, but replacement kits and specialist repair services exist. It can turn into a surprisingly satisfying little project.

Storage is another consideration. A modern phone can hold an enormous library, but an old iPod with a decent flash storage upgrade can still carry a ridiculous amount of music.

Would I use one as my only music player? Probably not. Would I use one for walks, travelling or keeping a dedicated offline music collection? Yeah, I can see the appeal. :)
Cashback on everything or it didn't happen

Shark

Not convinced that the iPod itself is making a comeback. People are talking about it because nostalgia is having a massive moment with everything from old cameras to MP3 players.

There is a difference between finding an old device interesting and wanting to use it every day. My phone does music, maps, messages, payments, podcasts and about twenty other things without needing another gadget in my pocket.

For a dedicated music player, though, I can understand the argument. Especially for kids. Giving a teenager a music player with no social media on it could be a pretty useful compromise.

You could load it with a few hundred albums, hand over some decent wired headphones and let them get on with listening. No notifications popping up every thirty seconds.

That might be more interesting than the retro angle. The old technology is being rediscovered because some of its limitations are actually useful.

Isla

One practical use that gets overlooked is exercise. A cheap old music player is much less stressful to take running than a £1,000 phone.

Drop the phone and you are potentially having a very expensive bad day. Drop a battered old iPod and you might just have a scratched iPod.

They are also useful for flights. Download everything beforehand and you do not need to think about streaming, airplane Wi-Fi or whether your subscription is going to behave properly.

The battery life on some of them was surprisingly good too. Modern phones are powerful, but streaming Bluetooth audio while doing other things can make the battery disappear fairly quickly.

The main obstacle is headphones. Plenty of people have moved to wireless earbuds, so carrying a dedicated player plus wired headphones feels like going backwards. For anyone who still likes wired audio, though, it makes much more sense.

WaveFunction30

There is another angle here: privacy. An iPod does not need to know where you are, what adverts you clicked, which songs you skipped or what else you are doing while listening to music

Obviously an old device is not some magical privacy shield, especially if you connect it to a computer. But compared with carrying a smartphone that is constantly connected to services, it is refreshingly limited

The offline nature is useful as well. I have a local music collection that I keep backed up, and having a separate player means I can listen without depending on a streaming account

People sometimes laugh at downloading MP3s now, but there is something comforting about owning a folder of music and knowing it will still play years from now

The iPod was never perfect, but the basic idea of keeping a personal music library in your pocket was pretty revolutionary. That part has not really gone away

Ava82

My take is slightly different: the best thing about the iPod was not the hardware, it was what it did to music collections. Suddenly carrying hundreds or thousands of songs became normal

Before that, you had CDs, cases, shelves and eventually portable CD players that skipped if you looked at them the wrong way. The iPod made a personal library feel genuinely portable

Streaming has made that seem ordinary now, but it is worth remembering how big that change was. Going on holiday with your whole music collection in your pocket felt almost ridiculous at the time

Would I go back to one permanently? Probably not. I like being able to switch between music, podcasts and audiobooks on my phone too much

But if someone handed me a working iPod and a pair of wired headphones, I would happily spend an afternoon loading albums onto it. There are worse ways to rediscover your old music collection. ;)

Related Topics (5)