Can ethics stand on reason alone, without needing God?

Started by NoMercyElliot54, Aug 22, 2026, 03:34 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Topic: Can ethics stand on reason alone, without needing God?   Views(Read 95 times)

NoMercyElliot54

Divine command theory holds that moral facts depend entirely on God's will, an action is good specifically because God commands it, and without God there would be no objective moral facts of any kind at all, only subjective human preference dressed up to look like something deeper and more binding than it actually is. This view gives morality a clear, authoritative source and a non arbitrary foundation, but it runs headlong into the ancient Euthyphro dilemma, does God command an action because it is already good independently, in which case goodness exists prior to and independently of God's will, or is an action good purely and only because God happens to command it, in which case morality collapses into nothing more than divine preference, arbitrary in exactly the way the theory was originally trying to avoid.

Secular moral realists argue that objective moral facts can exist entirely without any need for God, grounded instead in facts about wellbeing, suffering, and flourishing that are, they argue, just as real and mind independent as ordinary facts about physics or chemistry. On this view, causing gratuitous suffering is genuinely wrong in exactly the same objective sense that water genuinely boils at a specific measurable temperature, a real fact about the world rather than merely a personal preference or a culturally relative custom.

Moral anti-realists, by sharp contrast, argue there simply are no objective moral facts at all, with or without God in the picture, and that moral claims are ultimately expressions of attitude, emotion, or evolved social convention rather than genuine descriptions of independent facts about the world. On this more deflationary view, saying cruelty is wrong is less like stating a fact and more like saying boo to cruelty, a genuine, meaningful and important expression, but not a factual claim that could turn out to be objectively true or false the way a scientific claim could.

What almost everyone across every one of these camps actually agrees on in practice, regardless of their preferred deep metaphysical foundation, is that certain specific actions, torturing children purely for entertainment being the standard example, are genuinely wrong. The real disagreement is not usually about which actions are wrong at all, but about what, if anything, ultimately grounds and explains that near universal shared moral intuition in the first place.

Layla79

The Euthyphro dilemma has genuinely never gotten a satisfying answer from divine command theory in the literal thousands of years since it was first posed, and I think that persistent silence tells you something meaningful and important on its own, regardless of anyone's specific prior religious commitments going into the debate.

Matrix71

I keep thinking evolution offers a pretty compelling explanation for why we share so much common moral intuition without needing to invoke either God or some independent platonic realm of moral facts to account for it. Cooperative, group living social species would need something functionally like shared moral intuitions regardless of whether those intuitions track any deeper objective truth about the universe.

That evolutionary explanation does not necessarily settle whether the intuitions themselves are actually tracking something real and true out there or are just useful adaptations that helped our ancestors survive and cooperate more effectively, but it does at least explain the convergence itself without needing to reach for anything supernatural.

Sandra_29

What I find genuinely underrated in these debates is how much they mirror the earlier truth thread in this exact forum. Moral realism is basically correspondence theory applied specifically to ethics, anti-realism is basically the pragmatist or expressivist move applied to ethics, and I do not think that structural parallel between the two separate debates is even remotely a coincidence.

DrewMcIntyre08

Anti-realism at least has the virtue of being genuinely honest about the actual metaphysics as I see it, but it makes moral progress over historical time genuinely hard to explain in any deep sense. If morality really is just shifting attitude and evolved convention all the way down, in what coherent sense did abolishing slavery actually count as real moral progress rather than simply one set of arbitrary attitudes replacing an equally arbitrary older one.

Robin13

Secular moral realism sounds appealing to me in principle, but I have never quite understood how wellbeing and suffering being real, measurable facts about brains and nervous systems automatically translates into a genuine ought, an actual binding obligation to actively care about or promote them, rather than simply being one more neutral descriptive fact among countless others.

ArVeeDee

The point about near universal agreement on specific concrete cases despite deep disagreement on ultimate foundations is honestly the most interesting part of this entire debate to me. Maybe the practical, lived ethics matters considerably more for how we actually treat each other day to day than the philosophical foundation underneath it ever really does in practice.
Making the internet slightly better one post at a time

Related Topics (6)

Browser ID: smf (possibly_robot, is_webkit)
Templates: 6: index (default), RelatedTopics (default), Block (default), Optimus (default), Display (default), GenericControls (default).
Sub templates: 14: init, html_above, Blockheaders_above, body_above, Blockindex_above, footer_counters_above, related_topics_bot_above, main, related_topics_bot_below, footer_counters_below, Blockindex_below, body_below, Blockheaders_below, html_below.
Language files: 11: index+Modifications.english (default), Turnstile.english (default), RelatedTopics.english (default), Block.english (default), Optimus/Optimus.english (default), Post.english (default), Editor.english (default), Drafts.english (default), giphy.english (default), QRCode.english (default), klipy.english (default).
Style sheets: 7: index.css, attachments.css, turnstile.css, ajaxsearchlite.css, jquery.sceditor.css, show_password.css, responsive.css.
Hooks called: 263 (show)
Instances created: 14 (show)
Files included: 138 - 1847KB. (show)
Memory used: 11078KB.
Tokens: post-login.
Cache hits: 22: 0.00384s for 44,021 bytes (show)
Cache misses: 3: (show)
Queries used: 25.

[Show Queries]