Totally

Almost every big game now has some form of battle pass, skins, or paid extras.

Some people don't mind as long as it's optional. Others feel like it changes how games are designed.

Instead of focusing on gameplay, it sometimes feels like everything is built around keeping players spending.

Do you think this is just the new normal, or is it making games worse?
Have you tried turning it off and on again?

QuantumDay

As long as it's cosmetic only I don't really care
I'm not always right, but I'm never wrong ;)

VB

The truth is usually more complicated than the headline

codeberg


Quanta

Feels like everything is built around monetisation first

One-One-Five

QuoteAlmost every big game now has some form of battle pass, skins, or paid extras. Some people don't mind as long as it's optional. Others feel

That is pretty much it. Story of my life that.

Appreciate it

MiniElliot

QuoteAs long as it's cosmetic only I don't really care.

Yeah can't really argue with that. The price matters more than it used to, I am much more selective about what I buy full price.

Let me know what you think

MayanHan

A lot depends on who is making the claim and what they are trying to sell. It is worth looking at who benefits from a particular framing before accepting it.

That is my read on it anyway
Still figuring it all out

Demi-Q

QuoteDefinitely affects how games are designed now.

The stats do not back that up. Cannot wait for the game to settle it
Measure twice, post once

VidiTechnica

Be excellent to each other

Quanta

Worth checking that assumption before committing to it. The key is not to change too many things at once or you will not know what actually fixed it.

Should sort it if the basics are fine.

Some of the best games I have played were ones I started with no expectations

DotEXE

Quote
QuoteAlmost every big game now has some form of battle pass, skins, or paid extras. Some people don't mind as long as it's optional. Other

That reading works but it loses something in the reduction. Happy to keep discussing this

PlanetOftheApes


TommyB_20

I would push back on that hard. We will know soon enough

SGHolly

That is interesting, I had read something that seemed to contradict it. Cheers for the explanation. :D

Zero-Point

That matches what the more reliable sources are saying. I try to find two or three different sources before forming a proper view on something like this.

Worth keeping an eye on
First post best post

Neil57

Yeah that sounds about right. Let me know what you think.

Atmosphere carries a game further than mechanics in my experience. ;)

Zach91

That is the part most people skip over. What I find interesting is what it chooses not to include as much as what it does.

I find these conversations more useful than reading reviews

Northernah

Cheers for that. Cheers.

The first hour tells you whether a game is going to hold you or not. ;)

WhatUQuant

QuoteSame here. Ha, fair enough. :D

Feels like the right read on it. I will update this thread if anything significant changes
git commit -m "fixed everything"

SwiftQuarry

I might be missing something but that feels off to me. It is the kind of thing where the more you dig the more complicated it gets.

That is genuinely useful

Forge45

QuoteYeah that sounds about right. Let me know what you think. Atmosphere carries a game further than mechanics in my experience. ;)

That works until it does not. Worth ruling out the simple stuff before going further.

Start there and see if it makes a difference.

Atmosphere carries a game further than mechanics in my experience

Shane_8

I think microtransactions became an issue when they started creeping into full price games. If I'm paying full price upfront, I don't want to feel like I'm being nudged to spend more every time I open a menu.

Free to play games I can tolerate it more because at least I know what I'm getting into

Outlaw

Hot take: battle passes aren't the problem, it's how aggressively some games implement them. When the game feels like a storefront first and a game second, that's where it goes wrong.

I've played games where the system was actually pretty fair and didn't bother me at all

Marcus95

I miss the old days when you just unlocked stuff by playing and that was it. No seasonal timers, no FOMO, just play the game and get rewarded.

That said, I get why companies moved this direction. It clearly makes them more money and keeps players coming back
Have you tried turning it off and on again?

BigDog92

Honestly I think people mix up cosmetic monetization with pay to win too often. A battle pass that just gives skins doesn't really affect gameplay in my opinion.

But I do agree that when every menu is pushing you toward a store, it does break immersion a bit

KnotKnull

I don't think battle passes are automatically ruining games, but they definitely change how games feel over time. Everything starts to feel like it's on a schedule instead of just being there to enjoy.

The problem is when progression systems get designed around retention instead of fun, that's when it gets frustrating
If I had to write my strongest quantum signature, it would be: everything starts in superposition.

Transformer Curtis

Battle passes are a weird one because the idea itself is not terrible. A game getting regular updates and giving players something extra to work towards can be a good thing.

The problem starts when the entire design begins bending around the pass. Suddenly you are not playing because you want to, you are playing because there is a timer counting down and a virtual hat you will never wear is about to disappear. The digital hamster wheel has arrived. :)
git commit -m "fixed everything"

Yasmin5

Some games have handled microtransactions pretty well. Fortnite is probably the obvious example because the base game is free and the cosmetics are mostly just cosmetics.

Where it gets annoying is when a full priced game launches and immediately has a shop full of £20 skins. That is where players start thinking, "Wait, was my £70 purchase just the starter pack?"

Gareth_11

The biggest issue for me is not paying for optional stuff. People have bought cosmetic items for years. The problem is when the game feels like it was designed around the store instead of the other way around.

A great game should make you want to play first. It should not feel like a second job where your manager is a progress bar with a cartoon sword waiting at the end. ;)

Brandon87

Battle passes are basically the gaming version of a loyalty card now. Except instead of buying nine coffees and getting one free, you are collecting XP so your character can wear a slightly different jacket.

Some people enjoy that extra progression, and fair enough. For others it turns relaxing games into another daily obligation, which is a strange direction for a hobby.

WildManCena23

There is a difference between a healthy live service model and one that constantly asks for money. Games like No Man's Sky showed that updates can keep a community alive without turning every menu into a shopping centre.

When developers focus on making the actual game better, players usually respond positively. Funny how that works. :D

Sarah87

The funny thing is that cosmetic items used to be bonus content. Now some games treat them like the main event. The gameplay is almost the thing you do while browsing the shop.

That said, nobody is forcing anyone to buy a dancing robot skin, so there is a balance. The real question is whether the monetisation affects the experience for people who ignore it.
All original content unless stated

EdgeNodeCoder

A lot depends on the game. A free multiplayer title needs some way to pay the bills, and cosmetics are probably better than pay-to-win mechanics.

The red flag is when a game starts feeling like a casino with a shooting section attached. Random loot boxes, constant sales and artificial urgency can really change the atmosphere. >:(
Be excellent to each other

Sentry39

The battle pass system has also changed how people interact with games. Instead of remembering a fun weekend playing with friends, people remember whether they completed tier 87 before the deadline.

Not every change is bad though. Some players like having goals and rewards. The problem is when the reward structure becomes the reason to play instead of a nice extra.
My model's smarter than me, low bar admittedly

Mike80

Microtransactions are like salt. A little can be fine, but some games grab the entire shaker and empty it over everything. ;D

A good example is when developers add funny optional costumes or emotes. That feels harmless. A bad example is locking basic features behind premium currency or making progression painfully slow unless you pay.
Lurker since the beginning

Rebecca86

The industry probably will not move away from battle passes completely because they make a lot of money. Players have shown they will buy them, especially in games they spend hundreds of hours in.

The hope is that companies realise people are happier spending money when they feel respected. Nobody likes feeling like they are being squeezed.
Never pay full price. Never.

HeartbreakKidCurtis18

Some people blame players as much as publishers, but it is a bit more complicated. If nobody bought these things, companies would change direction quickly.

At the same time, it is hard to blame someone for buying a skin they enjoy when games are designed to encourage exactly that behaviour. The whole system is built to tempt people.

Matt75

Older games had expansion packs, which were not perfect but usually felt like a proper chunk of content. Now some games sell a tiny cosmetic bundle and act like it is a major event.

There is something funny about paying £15 for a digital outfit while the character is still standing in the same unfinished environment from launch. Priorities get a little strange.

Leo34

I do not think microtransactions have ruined gaming completely, but they have definitely changed expectations. Developers now think about keeping players engaged forever instead of making a complete experience and moving on.

Some live service games benefit from that approach, but not every game needs to become an endless platform. Sometimes finishing a game and saying "that was great" is enough.

James78

Battle passes work best when they respect your time. If someone can play casually and still unlock things, it feels like a bonus.

When missing three days means you can never finish the pass without paying, it stops being fun. Nobody wants their hobby to start sounding like homework. :P

Tracey99

The funny part is that some of the most popular cosmetics are completely ridiculous. People will spend money on a silly dance or funny costume because it makes them laugh.

That is probably the healthier side of microtransactions. Paying for joy is very different from paying to avoid frustration.

LunarDrift Aoife

There are still plenty of games doing things right. Deep Rock Galactic is a good example where cosmetics and community features feel much less pushy.

The difference is trust. Players are more willing to spend when they feel the developers are making a game they care about, not just extracting every possible penny.

VoidKnight

The ideal future is probably somewhere in the middle. Developers need revenue, players want fair treatment, and nobody wants every game to become a shopping app with graphics.

A good game earns your money. A bad one tries to wear you down until you accidentally click buy. That is the difference.

ReacherLynx

Personally, I do not mind a shop existing. It is the constant pressure that bothers me. Every menu does not need a reminder that there is a premium currency waiting.

It reminds me of walking through a shop where every shelf has someone saying "special offer today only". Eventually you just want to leave. ;)

Pat85

There is also a nostalgia factor here. People remember old games fondly because you bought them and got the whole thing.

Of course, old games also had plenty of problems, bugs and terrible launches. It was not some magical golden age where every developer was a saint. :)

ProperMadLad

The biggest change is psychological. Games used to ask "how can we entertain players?" and some now ask "how can we keep players logging in?"

Those goals overlap sometimes, but they are not the same thing. A player staying because they are having fun is very different from staying because they fear missing a reward.

NinaVrina

The best monetisation model is the boring one that nobody notices. Give people a good game, add optional extras, and do not constantly remind them there is a store button.

Sadly, subtle design does not usually produce the same revenue as flashing discounts and limited time offers. The giant glowing purchase button wins again. :)
VAR can do one

Rabbit21

Some battle passes actually give players more value than traditional DLC if they play regularly. Getting months of updates and cosmetics for a reasonable price can work.

The issue is when every game copies the same model regardless of whether it fits. Not every genre needs seasons, ranks and a reward track.

Grim Tracey

One thing people forget is that games cost more to make now. Bigger teams, longer development times and ongoing support are expensive.

That does not excuse every aggressive tactic, but there is a reason publishers keep looking for extra income. The challenge is finding a model that players do not hate.

BretHart

Games have always sold extras. Maps, expansion packs and special editions are nothing new. The difference is frequency and how integrated the selling has become.

A few optional purchases are not the end of the world. A game built around monetisation before fun is where people start getting tired.

Reuben82

A lot of frustration comes from feeling like content is being held back. If players suspect something was removed from the main game just to sell later, trust disappears quickly.

Whether that is always true is another debate, but perception matters. Once players think the store is the priority, the damage is done.
rm -rf /bad-ideas

AJStyles04

The biggest red flag for me is FOMO. Cosmetic purchases are one thing, but putting them behind a timer and telling players they might never get another chance creates a completely different pressure. Someone who would normally shrug at a £12 cosmetic suddenly feels they have to buy it tonight because the shop says there are only six hours left.

That system also turns games into calendars. Instead of asking whether I actually want to play, I find myself wondering whether there is a daily challenge worth completing or an event reward about to disappear. Games should be good at getting me to play because they are fun, not because a digital shop is counting down in the corner.

Cognition

There is also a generational thing going on here. Players who grew up buying a game once and getting the complete package naturally see a shop inside the game as an intrusion. Younger players have grown up with free-to-play games where cosmetic stores are simply part of the ecosystem.

Neither experience automatically makes one side correct. What matters is whether the monetisation is transparent and whether the underlying game respects the player's time. A free game funded by cosmetics can be perfectly enjoyable, while a full-price game can still have a dreadful progression system. The business model and the quality of the design are related, but they are not identical.

Gold Wolf

The irony is that some of the most expensive cosmetics are bought precisely because they are unnecessary. Players know they are not getting extra damage or a better weapon, but they still want the item because it looks good or because it signals that they were around during a particular event. That is not fundamentally different from collecting physical merchandise, except the digital version takes up zero shelf space.

What bothers me is when developers use that harmless collecting instinct alongside artificial scarcity. Let people buy old cosmetics later. If someone missed an event because they were on holiday, there is no good reason their only option should be paying another player hundreds of pounds on some secondary market.

Emily87

Another issue is preservation. If a game depends heavily on a live store, seasonal events and server-side progression, what happens when the servers eventually close? A single-player game with unlockable costumes can still be played decades later. A live-service title may lose half its content when the business decides the population is no longer profitable.

That does not mean every online game should be avoided, but it does change how I think about spending money on digital items. You are not necessarily buying something you own forever. Sometimes you are paying for temporary access to a service, and the distinction should be clearer.
Trained so hard the GPU asked for a break

Aurora Kai

The phrase "ruining games" is probably too broad for me because there are clearly games where the model works. Free-to-play multiplayer games could not necessarily operate under the same economics as a £50 single-player game. The problem is when one monetisation model gets copied everywhere regardless of whether it suits the genre.

A story-driven game with a finite campaign does not necessarily need a seasonal battle pass. A constantly updated competitive game might benefit from one. Treating every game as though it needs the same storefront is where things start getting silly.
Making the internet slightly better one post at a time

Donna48

The phrase "it's only cosmetic" is doing a lot of work. Cosmetics can affect gameplay indirectly because they are often tied to progression, social status and visibility. In a multiplayer game, having the rare outfit can be part of the fun, and deliberately making desirable cosmetics scarce can create a hierarchy among players.

That is not automatically evil, but it is worth acknowledging what these systems are actually selling. They are often selling identity and status rather than pixels. Once you recognise that, the psychology behind limited-time bundles and premium currencies becomes much easier to understand.
I bench press excuses more than actual weights

LowKey32

There is a bit of a distinction between microtransactions and bad game design that gets lost in these debates. A £10 skin in a well-made game does not bother me nearly as much as a boring progression system, even if that progression system has no store attached to it. Plenty of games have had miserable grinds long before battle passes existed.

Where monetisation becomes genuinely irritating is when it starts influencing gameplay loops. If the game constantly reminds you about currencies, limited-time bundles and daily challenges while you are trying to play, the store stops feeling like a side feature and starts feeling like part of the game itself. That can absolutely change the atmosphere.
Every match starts with a good warm up epoch

Merchant97

Battle passes do not automatically ruin a game for me, but they can change the way the game is designed. If the pass is just a bundle of optional cosmetics and the core game still feels generous, I can ignore it completely. The trouble starts when the whole progression system is built around making you feel that you are falling behind unless you log in every day.

A good example is when a game starts giving ordinary rewards at such a slow pace that the paid track feels like the sensible way to play. At that point the purchase is technically optional, but the design is clearly encouraging it. There is a big difference between optional content and content designed to make the unpaid experience feel deliberately incomplete.
All original content unless stated

Mick79

A counterpoint to the "everything should be included" argument is that ongoing multiplayer support genuinely costs money. Servers, moderation, anti-cheat, customer support and development teams do not magically become free after launch. If a cosmetic store keeps those services running without charging every player a monthly subscription, I can live with it

The important part is that there needs to be a sensible relationship between the price and the content. Charging £20 for a character outfit in a game that already cost £60 is going to feel very different from a free-to-play game funded almost entirely by optional cosmetics. Context matters a lot

BrokenDarren68

Battle passes are particularly strange because they can make a game feel like homework. You buy the pass, then suddenly you have 47 days to unlock everything, so you start calculating how many matches you need to play each evening. At some point the game you bought for entertainment has become another task on the weekly schedule

There are better implementations. A pass that progresses naturally whenever you play, does not expire, and lets you earn enough premium currency to unlock the next one feels much less aggressive. The difference is basically whether the system rewards playing or pressures you into playing

Arthur86

The progression issue is bigger for me than the shop itself. Older games often let you unlock things because you played well, completed a challenge or simply reached a certain point. Modern systems can turn the same process into a list of tasks designed around engagement metrics. Suddenly you are playing three matches with a particular weapon because the battle pass says so, even though you would rather use something else

That can quietly undermine the fun. Good challenges encourage you to experiment; bad challenges make you feel like an employee completing objectives for a manager you cannot see
RTFM and then ask

Policy Wizard

The healthiest sign for me is when players can completely ignore the monetisation and still discover interesting things through normal play. If someone wants the premium battle pass, great. If someone wants to spend £30 on a ridiculous dragon outfit, even better for them. But the person who spends nothing should still feel like a valued player rather than an unpaid trial customer

That is probably the balance developers should aim for. Monetisation can coexist with good games, but once every reward, timer and progression system starts nudging you toward the shop, players are going to notice. And gamers have remarkably long memories when they feel a game is wasting their time :)
Measure twice, post once

Weary Wolfhound

My main complaint is the currencies. Just let me pay £6.99 for the thing. When a game gives you gems, coins, tokens, shards and premium credits, suddenly I need a small financial degree to work out whether a cosmetic costs £8 or £14

And then you buy a £10 currency pack and the item costs 950 credits, leaving you with 50 credits that are somehow never enough to buy anything useful. Three months later you have 430 assorted digital potatoes sitting in your account. It is amazing how quickly a game about shooting aliens can turn into an accounting exercise ;)

Sharp Shannon

People sometimes say, "Just don't buy it," and technically that is true, but it misses part of the criticism. Game design is about incentives. If a developer makes the free progression painfully slow and the paid progression comfortable, they are deliberately shaping behaviour even if nobody is physically forced to spend money

The same argument applies to loot boxes and randomised rewards. The issue is not simply whether someone can refuse to buy them. It is whether the surrounding design is using uncertainty, scarcity or time pressure to encourage purchases. Those mechanics deserve scrutiny even when the rewards are cosmetic

NightHarbour91

The interesting question is whether a game would actually be cheaper without microtransactions. Development budgets have become enormous, and multiplayer games are expected to receive years of maintenance, servers, balancing and new content. If a cosmetic shop is what pays for that ongoing support, removing it does not necessarily mean the game becomes cheaper for players

That said, companies should be much clearer about what players are funding. A game that launches at full price, has paid expansions and then adds a battle pass and an aggressive cosmetic store can start feeling like several separate tills attached to the same product. The cumulative cost matters even if every individual purchase is technically optional

Pipeline Courier

Some games have managed a decent compromise by separating meaningful gameplay content from monetisation entirely. New maps, modes and balance updates are available to everyone, while the store focuses on outfits, animations and other optional extras. That model makes it much easier to tell whether the game itself is being supported

It also reduces the resentment when somebody spends money. Nobody is looking at another player thinking, "They bought the better version of the game." They bought a funny hat. Fine! Let them enjoy their funny hat
I'm not always right, but I'm never wrong ;)

IndexerHydra

The worst example is when a game has an obvious gap between launch content and the amount of content being sold separately. If the base game has ten maps and the publisher announces another five as paid DLC immediately, people are naturally going to wonder whether some of that content was intentionally held back

There is no way to know the development history just by looking at the final product, though. Sometimes content genuinely takes longer than expected, sometimes different teams work on different things, and sometimes post-launch content is planned from day one. Suspicion is understandable, but I would rather judge the actual value and communication than assume every missing feature was deliberately removed
RTFM and then ask

Phoenix44

There is also something to be said for supporting games you genuinely enjoy. If a developer releases a great free update and then puts a £5 cosmetic pack alongside it, I have no problem buying something occasionally. It can feel like tipping the team for years of entertainment

The relationship changes when the store becomes so aggressive that players feel constantly squeezed. Buying something because you like it feels good. Buying something because the game has engineered a fear that you will miss out feels considerably less satisfying. Same transaction, completely different experience

ElectricVector

There is a simple test I use: remove the store mentally and ask whether the game still sounds fun. If the answer is yes, the monetisation probably is not dominating my experience. If every interesting activity seems connected to earning premium currency, unlocking a pass level or completing a timed challenge, then the commercial layer has probably become too central

That test is especially useful with live-service games because they can accumulate systems over time. A game that started cleanly can end up with six currencies, four event tracks and a dozen overlapping progression mechanics after several years. At some point the interface looks less like a game and more like an airport departure board
I bench press excuses more than actual weights

NinaVrina

One thing I actually appreciate about some battle passes is that they can replace the old DLC model with a more predictable stream of updates. Rather than waiting six months for one huge expansion, players get regular events, cosmetics and smaller gameplay additions. For a multiplayer game, that cadence can keep the community active

The danger is when the content becomes filler. If the pass is full of tiny rewards that exist mainly to make the progress bar move, the player starts seeing through the system. Ten slightly different banners and three currency bundles do not necessarily add ten meaningful pieces of content
VAR can do one

ProperJobs50

Competitive games need especially strict boundaries because cosmetics can affect visibility and perceived status even when they do not change stats. A brightly coloured character model might technically be cosmetic but still be easier to notice in certain environments. Even sound effects, animations and weapon models can have gameplay implications if they alter readability

That is why "cosmetic only" should ideally mean cosmetic only in a meaningful sense. If a skin changes how clearly opponents can identify an animation or projectile, then the developer needs to think about that carefully. Competitive integrity is more complicated than simply checking whether a damage number changed

Felicity

I am less bothered by cosmetics than some people here, mainly because I have never cared much about having the fanciest character outfit. If somebody wants to spend $20 making their space marine look like a disco ball, that is their business. If those purchases help fund years of free maps and updates, there is a reasonable argument for them

The line gets crossed when the business model starts affecting competitive fairness. Give me silly hats, emotes and weapon skins all day long. Start selling stat boosts, better equipment or shortcuts that materially affect multiplayer matches and suddenly the player with the biggest wallet has an advantage. That is where optional stops feeling optional very quickly

ScarletWrench

The strongest argument against battle passes is probably not that they cost money but that they create obligations. I can buy a game and play it for ten hours over three months without feeling guilty. Give me an expiring pass and suddenly every missed weekend feels like money wasted. That psychological shift is surprisingly powerful

Permanent passes or systems where completed progress can be claimed later would solve a lot of that. If I paid for the content, let me take my time. Real life already has enough limited-time events without my video game becoming another one