PSA thread: your backup is not a backup until you have tested a restore

Started by QuantumFoam, Jul 03, 2026, 08:17 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Topic: PSA thread: your backup is not a backup until you have tested a restore   Views(Read 218 times)

QuantumFoam

Prompted by a friend losing ten years of photos this week, consider this the board's semi regular backup sermon and an open thread for questions. The rule that matters is 3-2-1, three copies of anything important, on two different types of storage, with one copy off site or in the cloud

The part everyone skips is the last step, actually testing a restore. A backup you have never restored from is a hope, not a backup. Pick one random file from your backup today and get it back onto your machine, if that little exercise fails you want to find out now and not during a house fire

Common traps worth naming, an external drive permanently plugged into the same machine dies with it in a power surge and gets encrypted with it in a ransomware event, cloud sync is not backup because it faithfully syncs your deletions and corruption, and RAID protects against a dead drive, not against you deleting the wrong folder

Post your current setup below and the board will kindly point out its weak spot, or ask for a recommendation for your situation and budget. No setup is too embarrassing, the embarrassing thing is having nothing
Making the internet slightly better one post at a time

AustinTheory18

Setup: everything on one external drive in the same bag as the laptop. I know. I KNOW. Telling on myself so someone makes me fix it
Here more than I should be

MondayMoan

That is not a backup, that is a matched set for a thief. Cloud copy tonight, drive stays at your mums by Friday

HeartbreakKid_Fan

The sync is not backup point needs shouting. Watched someone lose a thesis because a cloud drive dutifully synced the corrupted file across every device

Cass81

Versioning solves that though, most decent cloud services keep 30 days of file history. Check yours before paying for anything new
I read every reply. Even the bad ones.

Mick79

NAS owner checking in with the smug face, until last month when I realised my NAS was my only copy and it lives under the same roof as everything else

Ben

The off site copy is the one everyone skips because it is the only one requiring an actual habit. Automate it or it will not happen

ParallelSelf90

For photos specifically, do people trust the big photo clouds as one of the three copies or do they count as zero?

Highland Dylan

Count them as one copy, never as the only one. Accounts get locked for daft reasons and support is a lottery

Shane96

Test restore report, tried recovering one file as instructed and discovered my backup software had been silently failing since March. This thread has already paid for itself

Sam92

March! And the only reason you know is a forum post. Everyone reading this, go check yours right now, we will wait

Nadir Outlaw

A restore test should include older files, not just something created yesterday. Some corruption or accidental deletion can go unnoticed for months, so a backup with only a short retention window may faithfully preserve the problem instead of the good version. Keep enough history for the kind of mistakes you're trying to recover from

Mark94

Learned this one the expensive way: the backup software was running every night, but a directory had been excluded months earlier when I changed the configuration. Everything else looked fine. Now I check the backup logs for warnings and occasionally compare the list of backed-up folders against the folders I actually use
Making the internet slightly better one post at a time

RheaRipley

There's a difference between verifying files and testing a disaster recovery plan. A checksum can show that a file matches the version originally backed up, but it doesn't prove that you can boot a replacement machine, reinstall the necessary software or find all the credentials required to get working again

Barry1

Right, taking the hint and checking mine now. The scheduled job says it ran, but I haven't restored anything since I bought the drive last year. Today's task is to recover a few photos and a spreadsheet to another folder and make sure they open. Better to discover a problem while the originals are still safe!

Wizard

Worth checking the boring details too: passwords, encryption keys and recovery codes. A perfectly intact encrypted backup isn't much use if the only person who knows the password has forgotten it. Store recovery information somewhere separate and secure

Sequence48

The best backup plan is one you can afford to maintain. A £500 enterprise NAS with complicated redundancy isn't automatically better for a home user than a couple of sensible external drives and a cloud copy. RAID can help with drive failure, but it isn't a substitute for a separate backup
VAR can do one

NeonPhantom39

An external drive permanently plugged into the computer is convenient, but ransomware can potentially encrypt it along with everything else. Mine gets connected for a backup, then disconnected and put away. It's a little less automatic, but it gives me a copy that a compromised PC can't immediately reach

EventHorizon47

Cloud sync and backup aren't quite the same thing. If you accidentally delete a folder and that deletion syncs everywhere, you may have lost the folder from every device. Version history and a proper backup with retention can help, but check the actual recovery options rather than assuming they exist

Lantern98

Quick question: does anyone have a good method for testing a full system image without keeping a spare computer around? Individual file restores are easy enough, but I'd like to know whether the whole Windows installation could actually be recovered if the SSD died

NightHarbour91

This is the bit people skip because a backup job saying "completed successfully" feels reassuring. It only proves that something was copied, not that the files are readable or that you know how to get them back. Every few months, I restore a handful of random files and open them to check

Ann13

For anyone using Windows File History, don't assume the presence of the backup drive means every folder you care about is included. Check the configured locations and restore a file from an older date. Downloads, application data and files stored outside the usual libraries can be easy to overlook
404: Signature not found

Shannon91

Photos are the big one for me. You can reinstall Windows and download most programs again, but ten years of family pictures aren't coming back from a download link. My photos are on the PC, an external drive and a cloud service, and I periodically open older images from both backup locations

PaleSentinel

Not every backup needs to be a byte-for-byte image of the entire computer. Personal files may need frequent backups, while an operating system can often be reinstalled and applications downloaded again. The right mix depends on whether reinstalling everything would take twenty minutes or an entire working week

Anthony92

There's also the human side of this. If you're the only person in the household who knows how the backups work, what happens if you're away or unavailable when a computer fails? A simple written explanation of what's backed up and how to restore it could save somebody a lot of stress
Don't take the ...

Josh93

Ransomware protection deserves a mention alongside restore testing. If backups are continuously writable from the everyday user account, an attacker who compromises that account may be able to destroy them too. Separate credentials, offline copies and restricted backup permissions reduce that risk

Wrench

My test routine is deliberately unexciting. Once a month I pick a few files, restore them, compare their sizes and open them; twice a year I do a larger restore test. If a backup system can't pass that little exercise, I want to find out on a Sunday afternoon rather than during a disaster

Ria88

For a full Windows recovery, make sure you know where the installation or recovery media is and how to boot from it. If your backup depends on a particular application, keep its installer and recovery instructions too. A backup is much more useful when the whole recovery process has been rehearsed
Cashback on everything or it didn't happen

HenryThierry

One thing I'd add is to test the restore process when you're calm enough to read the instructions. If your only copy of the recovery guide is saved on the dead computer, you've created an avoidable extra problem. Keep a short written checklist and the relevant recovery details somewhere accessible

Maverick50

A simple test that saved me a lot of grief was restoring my Documents folder to a completely different location. Don't restore over the originals for your first test! You want to prove the backup works without risking the files you still have

Neuer31

For laptops, I'd prioritise backing up before travelling. A stolen machine, spilled coffee or lost bag can take out both the computer and the only copy of your files in one go. An encrypted cloud backup is useful here, provided the upload has finished and you can recover access to the account

Related Topics (1)