Bitcoin Magazine's Quantum Issue argues quantum isn't coming for your bitcoin

Started by NeuralTrace, Oct 03, 2026, 05:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Topic: Bitcoin Magazine's Quantum Issue argues quantum isn't coming for your bitcoin   Views(Read 68 times)

NeuralTrace

Bitcoin Magazine has published a Quantum Issue, and one of its main pieces, by Brandon Black, argues that quantum computers are not a real threat to bitcoin any time soon. It is a deliberately bold counterpoint to a lot of the coverage we have discussed, including the NSA's new deadlines and IonQ's elliptic curve work. Black's view is that the quantum threat to bitcoin is mostly fear, uncertainty and doubt. I will keep this on the technology rather than prices

His first argument is that today's quantum computers are still very primitive. He says no quantum machine has yet computed anything beyond what a precocious six year old could manage, and that current devices need large amounts of power, setup time and post processing to do even small calculations. He also argues money does not guarantee progress, comparing the cost of NASA's Space Shuttle with SpaceX's much cheaper Falcon 9

He is sceptical of many recent claims too, saying a lot of so called breakthroughs are theoretical maths rather than hardware progress. He goes further, arguing that physics does not rule out fundamental limits, for example if quantum superposition is not perfectly continuous or if energy needs grow with problem size, which could make breaking bitcoin's cryptography impossible. His conclusion is that there is no evidence a cryptographically relevant quantum computer will be built within a decade. That is a very bold claim, and plenty of physicists would disagree

Interestingly, he still thinks bitcoin developers should keep working on post-quantum options. The article mentions proposals such as P2MR and P2TRv2, and post-quantum signature schemes including SPHINCS, SHRINCS and ML-DSA. So even the sceptics agree preparation is sensible, mainly because upgrading a decentralised system like bitcoin takes years of agreement. That seems a sensible middle ground

It is a provocative piece, and it clashes with the NSA describing the quantum threat as existential. My guess is a lot of quantum researchers would strongly disagree with the claim that machines may never work. Who do you find more convincing? And should bitcoin be moving faster on post-quantum upgrades regardless?


Lewis_43

Six year old comparison is funny, but a bit unfair. Early computers could not do much either

Nobody judged the internet by its first email. Progress is rarely linear at the start. Every technology looks silly at the start
Lurker since the beginning

Sandman_Finisher

The NSA setting a 2030 deadline tells you how intelligence agencies see it. They are not known for panicking over nothing. That said, governments protect secrets for decades, while bitcoin can change its rules if needed. The urgency is different. Bitcoin cannot afford to be the last to move

RayOfLight32

Interesting that a crypto magazine devoted a whole issue to this. Clearly readers are worried

Pieces like this probably aim to calm nerves as much as inform. Holders want reassurance more than nuance. Sceptical voices sell magazines too

Slate Kev

Money not guaranteeing progress is a fair point. Huge budgets do not automatically produce breakthroughs

But quantum funding now comes from many different companies trying different approaches, which is not the same as one slow government programme. Competition is the difference

Marnie84

He is right that upgrades take years in bitcoin. Agreeing on changes across a decentralised community is incredibly slow

That alone is a reason to start now, whatever the timeline for quantum machines. Waiting for proof of a threat could leave too little time

SegWit took years of argument. A signature change would be harder
Every match starts with a good warm up epoch

Walter

The argument that quantum computers might be fundamentally impossible is a minority view among physicists. Most researchers think the challenges are engineering problems rather than physics limits. Black may be right about timelines, but claiming they might never work is a big stretch

Coder46

Old coins with exposed public keys are the real worry, including early wallets that may never move. If a quantum computer arrives, those are the obvious targets

Nobody has a good answer for coins whose owners are gone. Freezing them would be controversial. Letting them be stolen would be worse

Marcus82

ML-DSA is one of the NIST standards we discussed in the post-quantum cryptography thread. Good to see bitcoin developers considering the same building blocks as everyone else. Larger signature sizes will be a challenge for block space though. Trade offs everywhere
Still figuring it all out

Related Topics (1)