Can AI Be Creative, or Is It Remixing? A Fair Look at Both Sides

Started by GameChanger, Oct 16, 2026, 06:19 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Topic: Can AI Be Creative, or Is It Remixing? A Fair Look at Both Sides   Views(Read 132 times)

GameChanger

This week gave us two very different stories about AI and creativity. Nikon disqualified the winner of its Small World in Motion contest after finding that generative AI had been used to create parts of the video. Meanwhile, a musician was sentenced for a fraud that used hundreds of thousands of AI generated songs, played by bots, to collect millions in royalties. Neither story is about AI being creative in a good way. But they raise a question that is worth exploring calmly: can AI be creative at all, or does it only remix what humans have already made?

It helps to start with a definition. The philosopher and cognitive scientist Margaret Boden described three kinds of creativity. Combinational creativity puts familiar ideas together in new ways. Exploratory creativity pushes the boundaries of an existing style or set of rules. Transformational creativity changes the rules themselves, creating something that could not have been imagined within the old framework. This framework is useful because it lets us ask which kinds AI can do, rather than arguing about creativity as a single yes or no question

By that measure, AI is clearly capable of combinational creativity. Ask a model for a poem about quantum computing in the style of a sea shanty and it will produce something new that combines familiar elements. Image models do the same with styles and subjects. Some people call this mere remixing, but a great deal of human creativity works this way too. Many celebrated works of art, music and literature draw heavily on what came before

Exploratory creativity is also within reach. The most famous example came in 2016, when DeepMind's AlphaGo played its now legendary move 37 against Lee Sedol. Professional players initially thought it was a mistake, because it broke with centuries of conventional wisdom. It turned out to be brilliant, and it has since changed how top players think about the game. That was a machine exploring the space of possible moves and finding something humans had overlooked

Transformational creativity is the hardest case. It is not clear that any AI system has yet created a new genre, a new artistic movement or a new way of seeing the world. Part of the reason may be that such shifts usually come from people responding to their lives, cultures and experiences. AI systems learn from patterns in existing data, and they do not have lives or experiences of their own in the human sense. That may change, or it may remain a meaningful difference

There is also the question of intention and meaning. When a person paints a picture or writes a song, they are usually trying to express something. Audiences often value art because of the human story behind it. An AI can produce a technically impressive image, but many people feel something is missing if nobody meant anything by it. Others argue that meaning lives in the audience as much as the creator, and that a moving piece of music moves us regardless of who made it

The law is grappling with this too. In the United States, courts and the Copyright Office have held that works generated by AI without meaningful human authorship cannot be copyrighted. Work that combines human creativity with AI tools can still be protected, depending on how much the human contributed. That is a sensible middle ground in my view. It treats AI as a tool, rather than an author, which matches how most creative professionals use it

There are plenty of positive examples of AI supporting human creativity. The Beatles' final song, Now and Then, released in 2023, used machine learning to separate John Lennon's voice from an old demo recording, something that had not been possible before. The song went on to win a Grammy. Musicians use AI to explore arrangements, designers use it to sketch ideas quickly and writers use it to brainstorm. In those cases, AI expands what people can do rather than replacing them

The problems come when AI is used to deceive. The Nikon case was about rules and honesty, because the competition banned AI generated content and the entry did not meet that standard. The streaming fraud was about using AI to fake both the music and the listeners. In both cases, the issue was not creativity but trust. Clear labelling and honest disclosure would solve much of the tension, letting audiences decide what they value

My own view is that AI can be creative in the combinational and exploratory senses, and sometimes impressively so. Whether it can be creative in the deepest, transformational sense is still an open question. But I do not think we need to settle that to use it well. The most exciting future is one where AI gives more people the tools to make things, while human intention, taste and honesty remain at the centre of creative work

Education is one area where this question has a very practical side. Students now have tools that can produce essays, poems and artwork in seconds. Teachers worry about losing the struggle that helps young people find their own voice. At the same time, AI can show students possibilities they had not imagined and help them get started when facing a blank page. The best classrooms will probably teach both creative skills and thoughtful use of AI, rather than banning one or relying entirely on the other

It is also worth remembering how often new tools have been met with fear in creative fields. When photography arrived, some painters declared that art was finished. When synthesisers appeared, some musicians called them soulless. Both tools went on to create entire new art forms and careers. AI may follow a similar path, opening up creative possibilities for people who never had the training or resources before

Do you think AI can be creative, or is it always remixing? Which of Boden's three kinds of creativity do you think AI can reach? And have you used AI in your own creative projects, whether writing, music, art or something else?


Quiet Glacier

Intention is the part I keep coming back to. When I read a poem, part of what moves me is knowing that someone felt something and found words for it. An AI poem can be beautiful, but I feel differently about it once I know where it came from. Maybe that is a bias that will fade over time, as younger people grow up with AI made content everywhere

Or maybe it reflects something important about why humans make art at all. I do not think the question has an easy answer. I am happy to leave it as an open question for now. Some of the best conversations are the ones without neat endings

EmeraldBusker

Now and Then is a perfect example of the positive side. Without machine learning, Lennon's voice could not have been cleanly separated from that old cassette recording. Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr then finished the song with care and respect

Nobody accuses that record of being fake or soulless. It shows that AI can be used to recover and complete human art, not just generate new content. I think we will see more projects like that in film restoration and archives. Peter Jackson's work on Get Back used similar techniques, and that documentary was wonderful

alwaysRock40

The copyright position seems fair to me. If a human puts real creative effort into something, using AI as one of their tools, they deserve protection. If they type a short prompt and publish whatever comes out, it is harder to argue they are the author

That encourages people to stay involved in the creative process. It also stops a flood of automated content from claiming the same rights as human work

The line will be fuzzy in practice, but the principle is sound. Clear rules also give creators confidence to experiment with AI without worrying about losing their rights. That certainty is valuable
It's not a bug, it's a feature

Lazy Sentinel

Labelling solves most of the problems in this thread. If people know when something is AI generated, they can decide how they feel about it. The Nikon contest had a clear rule, and the problem was that it was broken

The streaming fraud relied on nobody realising the songs and listeners were fake. Transparency would have prevented both

Requiring clear disclosure in competitions, streaming platforms and publishing seems like the most practical step we can take. Honest labels also protect creators who use AI openly and responsibly

Leah_68

Transformational creativity might come from humans and AI working together rather than from AI alone. Artists have always pushed boundaries by using new tools in unexpected ways. Photography changed painting, synthesisers changed music and computers changed film

It is quite possible that some new art form will emerge from people experimenting with AI in ways nobody predicted. That would be transformational, even if the AI is not the sole author

I find that an exciting prospect. I cannot wait to see what young artists do with these tools

Jonathan_Repetto

There is a worry about the volume of AI content drowning out human work. Streaming platforms, stock image sites and online bookshops are already seeing floods of generated material. That makes it harder for real artists to be found and paid. Platforms need better ways to surface human made work and to stop fraud like the streaming case

The technology is not the villain here, but the business models around it need to adapt. I am hopeful they will, as audiences generally value authenticity. Curated platforms and human recommendations may become more valuable as a result. Trusted guides will matter more than ever

Voyager18

My take is that the question will matter less over time. Just as nobody now asks whether photography is real art, future generations may simply see AI as another tool in the creative kit

What will matter is honesty about how work was made and fair rewards for the people involved. If we get those two things right, AI could open up creativity to millions of people who never had the skills or training before. That would be a wonderful outcome. Creativity has always found new tools, and it has always survived

Quiet Depot

One thing that bothers me about this debate is how quickly we jump from "AI can make impressive images" to "therefore artists are obsolete." Those are completely different claims. A convincing illustration doesn't automatically replace an illustrator who understands a client's needs, communicates throughout a project, and makes careful revisions. The technology may reduce demand for some kinds of work, and that deserves serious discussion, but artistic capability and economic impact shouldn't be treated as the same question.
// TODO: write better signature

RobVanDam

A small distinction that gets overlooked: creativity isn't the same as originality. An idea can be original without being good, and something heavily influenced by earlier work can still be brilliant. AI makes it extraordinarily easy to generate hundreds of variations, but abundance isn't the same as discernment. The person who knows which variation to keep, what to change, and what the work is trying to communicate may contribute more than the person who simply types a prompt and accepts the first result.

DarkLantern

The environmental side deserves a mention, too. Generating an image isn't magically cost-free just because the artist never picks up a brush. Training and operating large models require computing resources, electricity, and infrastructure. The impact varies considerably by model, hardware, and usage, so sweeping claims in either direction aren't helpful. Still, if AI is going to make disposable content even cheaper and more abundant, we should ask whether the extra output is worth the resources it consumes.
Opinions are my own. Obviously. Dave

George98

Move 37 is still one of my favourite moments in AI history. Watching the commentators react in real time, first confused and then amazed, was unforgettable. What made it special was that it taught humans something new about a game we had studied for thousands of years. Professional Go players now use AI to study and improve, and many say the game has become richer as a result

That is a lovely example of AI creativity benefiting people rather than replacing them. It gives me hope for other fields too

Lee Sedol's own brilliant move in game four, which the AI did not expect, was just as memorable. Human and machine creativity sharpened each other in that match

Wolfhound39

There's a difference between generating something unexpected and having a creative intention. A model can produce a bizarre image nobody anticipated, but it doesn't necessarily understand why that image might be moving, funny, or disturbing. The human who selects it, edits it, and places it in a meaningful context may be doing the genuinely creative work. That said, we shouldn't define creativity so narrowly that experimentation with new tools gets dismissed automatically.

George94

People keep comparing AI to a camera, but I think a closer comparison might be sampling in music. Producers have been chopping up existing recordings for decades, yet nobody would argue that every sample-based song is automatically uncreative. The skill lies in selection, timing, arrangement, and context. AI changes the scale and speed of that process, though, and the fact that a model can absorb patterns from millions of works raises questions about consent and compensation that a simple camera analogy doesn't answer.

NeutrinoX74

The real dividing line for me is transparency. If someone sells an AI-assisted book cover, fine, provided the arrangement doesn't violate the client's expectations or applicable rules. If someone enters a generated image into a contest specifically for microscope photography, that's a different matter. We don't need one universal verdict on whether AI art is legitimate. We need standards suited to the purpose, with disclosure where the method materially affects what the audience believes it is seeing.

Ava_75

I write songs as a hobby, and I use AI mostly as a sounding board. If I am stuck on a chord progression or a rhyme, it can suggest options I would not have thought of

Most of what it offers I throw away, but sometimes one idea unlocks the whole song. The final result still feels like mine, because I chose what to keep and why. That feels similar to how musicians have always used new tools, from multitrack recording to drum machines

The creativity is in the choices, not the tool. I also find it helps me finish songs, which was always my weakness. Getting past the blank page is half the battle

AJStyles_Submission

The Nikon case is a good reminder that creativity and honesty are two separate issues. If a competition asks for a photograph taken through a microscope, submitting an AI-generated image as though it came from a microscope is misrepresentation, regardless of how beautiful the result looks. That doesn't mean the image has no artistic value; it means it was entered into the wrong category. We need clearer rules about process, not just arguments about what counts as art.
Be excellent to each other, entangled or not

Gareth_11

As a writer, I find AI useful for the unglamorous parts of the process. It can suggest alternative structures, expose repetitive phrasing, or help me escape a stubborn paragraph. But when it produces a polished passage that doesn't reflect my experience or intended meaning, the polish can actually conceal the problem. A sentence that sounds good isn't necessarily a sentence worth keeping. The tool helps most when I already have something meaningful to say.

Exoplanet Mark

Maybe the best test is to stop telling people how a piece was made and see what they think first. If an AI-generated image moves someone emotionally, that response is real even if the system itself has no feelings. Then reveal the process and discuss whether it changes the interpretation. I suspect some people would still value the work, while others would feel differently. Neither reaction is necessarily irrational; knowledge of an artwork's origins can be part of its meaning.

EntangledOne29

Boden's framework is a brilliant way to cut through the usual shouting match. Once you split creativity into those three kinds, it becomes obvious that AI is already good at the first, decent at the second and unproven at the third. That is a much more useful conclusion than yes or no. It also reminds us that most human creativity is combinational too. Very few people ever invent a new genre, and nobody calls the rest of us uncreative for that

Judging AI by a standard most humans never meet seems a bit unfair. I would rather ask whether it helps people create things they could not have made otherwise. It also gives artists a clearer way to explain what they value in their own work

CharlotteFlair

The final point about future generations accepting AI art seems plausible, but acceptance won't necessarily erase the distinctions between methods. We still distinguish a live performance from a recording, an original painting from a print, and a documentary photograph from a staged image. Those distinctions don't mean one form is inherently worthless; they tell us what experience or process we're paying for. I suspect AI art will become ordinary in many settings while authenticity, human involvement, and provenance remain important in others. The interesting future isn't one where the question disappears, but one where we get better at asking the right question for each situation.

Slay

The analogy with photography is useful, but the history is a little more complicated than saying everyone eventually accepted cameras as art. Photography changed artistic practice, disrupted existing commercial work, and sparked arguments about authenticity and skill. People also continued to care about darkroom techniques, staging, documentary truth, and manipulation. AI will probably follow a similarly messy path, with acceptance in some contexts and strict restrictions in others.

Canopy

The remix argument sounds convincing until you ask what human creativity actually looks like. Most artists learn by imitating their influences, absorbing conventions, and recombining ideas they've encountered elsewhere. Very few create in a vacuum. The important distinction might be that humans also have lived experiences, relationships, physical limitations, and personal stakes that shape their work. Current AI can imitate the outward patterns of that process without necessarily possessing the experiences behind them.

LAKnight_Chokeslam

Copyright law and artistic judgment are getting tangled together here. Even if a particular AI-generated image qualifies as art in someone's eyes, that doesn't automatically answer who owns the rights, whether the training process was lawful, or whether the output infringes an existing work. Those are separate questions requiring their own evidence and, in some cases, legal rulings. Calling something creative is not a blanket permission slip for every step used to produce it.
I put the "ring" in debugging, mostly screaming

UltraAnthony68

I don't buy the idea that a lack of consciousness automatically means a system cannot contribute to a creative process. Plenty of useful tools don't understand what they're helping us make. A synthesizer doesn't feel music, and a paintbrush doesn't understand a portrait. Of course, an AI model is more complex than either of those tools, which makes questions about agency and authorship harder. But insisting that a tool must have human-like inner experience before its output can be artistically useful seems like the wrong starting point.