AI threatens our culture, but the greatest loss might be our ability to listen

Started by ShawnMichaels_Botch, Oct 04, 2026, 05:20 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Topic: AI threatens our culture, but the greatest loss might be our ability to listen   Views(Read 74 times)

ShawnMichaels_Botch

The Guardian has an opinion piece by Dr Shirleene Robinson, an oral historian and visiting fellow at the University of Technology Sydney, with a slightly different angle on what AI might cost us. Most worries about AI and culture focus on art, music and writing being replaced. Robinson argues that the bigger loss could be our ability to listen to each other. As AI offers instant answers and synthetic empathy, we may stop doing the slow, patient work of hearing other people out

She points to some striking research. Australians lost an average of 338 spoken words a day between 2005 and 2019, which adds up to around 120,000 words per person per year. That was before chatbots arrived, so screens were already eating into conversation. If people start talking to AI companions instead of friends and family, that trend could speed up. Phones were already crowding out conversation at dinner tables and on buses

As an oral historian, she knows the value of listening better than most. The National Library of Australia holds more than 58,000 hours of oral histories recording people's lived experiences across generations. She mentions voices like Dame Mary Gilmore, born in 1865, describing life before electricity, and Dr Ella Stack, the Darwin doctor who lived through Cyclone Tracy and served as mayor during the rebuild. Those recordings only exist because someone sat down and listened

Her key point is that listening to people from different backgrounds, who may not share our views, can improve our mental and physical wellbeing. Empathy, she argues, is the richest gift that listening offers. A chatbot tuned to agree with you and respond instantly does not teach patience or an appreciation of difference. Real people are slower, messier and more surprising

I think this is a thoughtful take, and it connects with the debates about AI companions and loneliness. Do you think AI is making us worse listeners? Have you noticed people talking to chatbots more than to each other? And what would you want recorded if someone made an oral history of your life?. Listening is a skill, and skills fade when we stop using them


Badger

Oral histories are wonderful. My grandad recorded his memories of the war before he died, and the family treasures it. Hearing his voice tell those stories means more than any written account. Everyone should record an older relative while they can
Powerbombed my keyboard, it deserved it

Theo90

Chatbots never interrupt, never get bored and never disagree in a way that hurts. That makes them easy to talk to. But it also means you never practise dealing with real people. Social skills are like muscles

Wolfhound39

I am not sure AI is the main culprit here. People stopped listening to each other long before chatbots. Social media turned conversation into broadcasting. AI is just the latest step along that road. Blaming it alone misses the bigger picture

NoMercyCass69

Listening to people you disagree with is the part I find most important. Online spaces sort us into bubbles

Real conversations with neighbours and colleagues force us out of them. Workplaces used to do that too. Remote work has reduced it for many people

Velvet Connor

This forum is a decent example of people listening to each other, most of the time. Long threads with disagreement are a dying art

Worth protecting. Keep the long replies coming, everyone

Red Wrench

Three hundred and thirty eight fewer words a day is a big drop. That was all before chatbots, so phones and streaming did most of that damage. AI will probably just accelerate it. Families eating with phones on the table did plenty of damage already

Joanne94

Cyclone Tracy survivors recording their stories is exactly the kind of history that matters. Official records miss what it felt like

Only people who were there can tell you that. Libraries doing this work deserve far more funding than they get

Isaac85

Synthetic empathy is a great phrase for what chatbots offer. It feels like being heard, but nobody is there

Lonely people might not notice the difference at first. That is the worrying part
I don't lose arguments, I just get disconnected