Would you rather forum edition: the workplace dilemmas nobody warns you about

[Client Wrench]

The classic game with a professional twist. The poster above leaves a work related Would You Rather, you answer with your actual reasoning, then set the next dilemma, and the rule as always is both options must genuinely cost something or the round is wasted

Working life throws up choices nobody prepares you for and this thread exists to enjoy them properly, the boring meeting versus the chaotic one, the boss who over explains versus the one who never explains anything, the office with too much noise versus the one with none

Reasoning is mandatory, a bare pick with no defence is a void turn, this is a debating society wearing a workplace costume, and the best answers usually reveal more about the person than the dilemma itself

Opening dilemma to start us off. Would you rather have a boss who micromanages every tiny detail, or one who gives zero guidance and vanishes for weeks at a time?

[QueueJump58]

Zero guidance every time, silence I can work with, at least I get to make my own mistakes and learn from them, micromanaging removes the learning entirely and just makes me a nervous extension of someone else's anxiety

[ThreadNecro11]

Micromanaging for me actually, at least you know exactly what is expected, the vanishing boss leaves you guessing and then blindsided when their standards finally reappear out of nowhere at review time

[Kev5]

Next, would you rather attend a meeting that could have been an email every single day, or receive an email so long and unstructured it should have been a five minute meeting

[JustMartin]

The unstructured email every time, I can skim it and extract what matters, a pointless daily meeting steals a fixed chunk of my actual life that I never get back, the email at least respects my time even while wasting it

[TommyB_20]

The meeting for me, because a bad email chain becomes an archaeology project of forty replies, at least a meeting dies at the scheduled end time, some emails apparently live forever

[ProperJobs89]

Next, would you rather work with a brilliant colleague who is genuinely unpleasant to be around, or a mediocre one who is an absolute joy every single day

[SilverSurfer51]

The joyful mediocre colleague, competence I can build around or route around, a talented misery poisons every single day regardless of how good their output is, life is too short for brilliant unpleasant